首页|心灵为身体立法:出土文献与东周儒家的身心主从模式

心灵为身体立法:出土文献与东周儒家的身心主从模式

扫码查看
因帛书和上博简《五行》、郭店简《性自命出》和清华简《心是谓中》等新文献的发现,为重新认识东周儒家身心关系带来的契机之一,是能够看到一种不同于身心合一论和身心平行论的身心主从论(或模式).以主导被主导、役使被役使和君臣类比等表达出来,以心灵为身体立法、心灵主导和规范身体为形态的东周儒家这一模式,主要被限定在以伦理(如仁义礼)、理性(谋划)的心去规范耳目口鼻、四肢等感性的身体.这种模式在东周儒家传世文献和在其他诸子学中有类似的表达和表现,同希腊的身心模式对比一下,两者也有某种不约而默然的相似性.
Mind Makes Laws for Body:The Excavated Documents and Eastern Zhou Confucianist Master-Slave Mode of Mind and Body
One of the opportunities brought by the discoveries of new ancient documents such as the silk manuscripts(帛书),the inscriptions of The Five Elements(《五行》)on bamboo slips collected by Shanghai Museum(上博简),the inscriptions of Human nature is endowed by the Heaven(《性自命出》)on bamboo slips unearthed in Guodian(郭店简),and the inscriptions of Heart is in the middle of body(《心是谓中》)on bamboo slips collected by Tsinghua University(清华简),for a new understanding of the Eastern Zhou Confucianist's(东周儒家)view about the relationship between mind and body,is for us to see a"master-slave theory or mode of mind and body"(身心主从论)which is different from the unity theory of mind and body(身心合一论)and the parallel theory of mind and body(身心平行论).The Eastern Zhou Confucianist mode,expressed with the analogies between the dominating and the dominated,the enslaving and the enslaved,and the emperor and his ministers,in the forms of the law-making by mind for body,and the dominance and specification by mind for body,was mainly limited to the specification of such sensible body parts as the ear,the eye,the mouth,the nose and the limbs,by the ethical mind like benevolence,righteousness and ritual,and the rational mind like planning.This mode had similar expressions and presentations in the Confucianist documents handed down from the Eastern Zhou Dynasty and also in the works of other schools of thought.Compared with the ancient Greek mode of mind and body,there is also an implicit similarity between the two of them.

mindbodymake lawsexcavated documentEastern Zhou Confucianism(东周儒家)

王中江

展开 >

北京大学哲学系,北京 100871

心灵 身体 立法 出土文献 东周儒家

2024

北京大学学报:哲学社会科学版
北京大学

北京大学学报:哲学社会科学版

CSTPCDCSSCICHSSCD北大核心
影响因子:0.963
ISSN:1000-5919
年,卷(期):2024.61(3)