北京理工大学学报(社会科学版)2025,Vol.27Issue(1) :44-55.DOI:10.15918/j.jbitss1009-3370.2024.3074

《民法典》用人者替代责任的司法解释完善——兼论网络平台用工关系替代责任的法律适用

The Judicial Interpretation Improvement on Employer's Vicarious Liability under the Civil Code of China—And on Legal Application of Vicarious Liability Involving Employment Relationships Formed in Online Platform

王竹 帅仁策
北京理工大学学报(社会科学版)2025,Vol.27Issue(1) :44-55.DOI:10.15918/j.jbitss1009-3370.2024.3074

《民法典》用人者替代责任的司法解释完善——兼论网络平台用工关系替代责任的法律适用

The Judicial Interpretation Improvement on Employer's Vicarious Liability under the Civil Code of China—And on Legal Application of Vicarious Liability Involving Employment Relationships Formed in Online Platform

王竹 1帅仁策1
扫码查看

作者信息

  • 1. 四川大学 法学院,四川 成都 610207
  • 折叠

摘要

《民法典侵权责任编解释(一)》第 15 条将"用工单位劳务关系"和"个体工商户用工关系"纳入《民法典》第 1191 条第 1 款规定的"用人单位"替代责任的适用范围,但未能明确网络平台用工替代责任的法律适用规则.《民法典》第 1191~第 1193 条已构建"用人单位劳动关系—个人劳务关系—独立承揽关系"三分法用工关系谱系.应当以第 1191 条第 1 款为中心补正用工单位劳务关系替代责任规则的缺失,以第 1192 条为中心构建个体工商户用工关系替代责任法律适用框架,以第 1193 条为中心构建网络平台用工替代责任法律适用框架.

Abstract

Article 15 of the Interpretation on the Book of Tort Liability of the Civil Code(I)places"labor service relationship of employing entity"and"employing relationship of individual-run industrial and commercial households"within the scope of the"employer entity",where vicarious liability as stipulated in Article 1191,Paragraph 1 of the Civil Code of China shall be applied.However,it fails to clarify the rule of legal application for vicarious liability of employing relationships formed on online platforms.Articles 1191 to 1193 of the Civil Code of China establish a trichotomy of employment relationships:labor relationship based on employer entity,individual labor service relationship,and independent contracting relationship.It is necessary to center on Article 1191,Paragraph 1,to rectify the absence of vicarious liability rules for labor service relationships of employing entities.Article 1192 should be used as the basis to construct the legal application framework for vicarious liability in employing relationships of individual-run industrial and commercial households,while Article 1193 should form the legal application framework for vicarious liability in employing relationships on online platforms.

关键词

用人者替代责任/用人单位/用工单位/个体工商户/网络平台用工

Key words

employer's vicarious liability/employer entity/labor employing entity/individual-run industrial and commercial households/online platform employing

引用本文复制引用

出版年

2025
北京理工大学学报(社会科学版)
北京理工大学

北京理工大学学报(社会科学版)

CHSSCD北大核心
影响因子:0.785
ISSN:1009-3370
段落导航相关论文