《四库全书总目》评王赵交恶与赵执信诗论及诗
Comment on the Disagreement between Wang Shizhen and Zhao Zhishen and Zhao Zhishen's Poetry Theory and Poems in the General Contents of Si Ku Quan Shu
李兆禄1
作者信息
- 1. 山东航空学院人文学院,山东滨州 256603
- 折叠
摘要
《四库全书总目》对赵执信的批评集中于王(士禛)赵交恶、执信诗论与执信诗.《总目》认为,王赵交恶缘于执信请王士禛为其《观海集》作序而士禛屡失其期,流露出明显的扬王抑赵态度.《总目》指出执信诗论所自,肯定其诗学价值及揭出士禛诗歌弊病之举,但不满其以一己之说衡绳他人诗歌.《总目》充分肯定执信诗的成就,指出执信诗属"劖刻"一路.《总目》对赵执信的批评,代表了清代的官方态度与主流观点,影响深远.
Abstract
The criticism of Zhao Zhishen in the General Contents of Si Ku Quan Shu focuses on the disagreement between Wang Shizhen and Zhao Zhishen and Zhao Zhishen's poetry theory and poems.It believes that the disagreement between Wang Shizhen and Zhao Zhishen is due to Wang Shizhen's fre-quent overdue preface for Zhao Zhishen's Guanhai Collection,showing a clear attitude of promoting Wang Shizhen and suppressing Zhao Zhishen.It points out the origin of Zhao Zhishen's poetry theory and affirms his poetic value and exposure of the shortcomings of Wang Shizhen's poems,but it is dissat-isfied with the use of his own words to constrain the poems of others.It fully recognizes the achieve-ments of Zhao Zhishen's poems and points out that his poems are written in the way of"carefulness and strictness".The criticism of Zhao Zhishen in the General Contents of Si Ku Quan Shu represents the of-ficial attitude and mainstream viewpoint of Qing Dynasty,which has a profound impact.
关键词
《四库全书总目》/赵执信/王士稹/王赵交恶/执信诗论/执信诗Key words
General Contents of Si Ku Quan Sh u/Zhao Zhishen/Wang Shizhen/disagreement be-tween Wang Shizhen and Zhao Zhishen/Zhao Zhishen's poetry theory/Zho Zhishen's poems引用本文复制引用
出版年
2024
NETL
NSTL
万方数据