首页|不同施肥量和播种量对高寒矿区植被恢复和土壤质量的影响及综合评价

不同施肥量和播种量对高寒矿区植被恢复和土壤质量的影响及综合评价

扫码查看
木里煤矿区地处高寒地带,经多年开采后生态破坏严重,土壤贫瘠,导致生态恢复困难且恢复成本较高.因此,筛选出一套高效率、低成本的生态恢复方案尤为重要.试验依托于青海省大面积的恢复方案设计了不同施肥量和播种量组合的两因素三水平完全组合试验,施肥量设3个水平,分别为低施肥F1(羊板粪165 m3·hm-2+有机肥7.5 t·hm-2+牧草专用肥 75 kg·hm-2)、中施肥F2(羊板粪 330 m3·hm-2+有机肥 15 t·hm-2+牧草专用肥 150 kg·hm-2)、高施肥F3(羊板粪495 m3·hm-2+有机肥22.5 t·hm-2+牧草专用肥225 kg·hm-2);播种量设3个水平,分别为低播量S1(60 kg·hm-2)、中播量S2(120 kg·hm-2)、高播量S3(180 kg·hm-2),共构建了9种恢复处理,分别为低施肥低播量(F1S1)、低施肥中播量(F1S2)、低施肥高播量(F1S3)、中施肥低播量(F2S1)、中施肥中播量(F2S2)、中施肥高播量(F2S3)、高施肥低播量(F3S1)、高施肥中播量(F3S2)、高施肥高播量(F3S3).本研究主要通过探究不同恢复处理下矿区植被生长状况及土壤质量变化,结合灰色关联度分析和熵权TOPSIS方法,对不同恢复方案的综合效果进行全面评价.结果显示,施肥量与播种量的恢复处理显著促进了矿区的植被恢复(P<0.05),中高施肥处理下植被盖度超过70%,植被密度达到8826~10447株·m-2,地上生物量显著增加至445.51~559.47 g·m-2.不同恢复处理显著改善了土壤物理特性(P<0.05),中高施肥处理下土壤容重平均降至0.94 g·cm-3,随施肥量的增加,自然含水量显著增加,在高施肥中播量(F3S2)和中施肥高播量(F2S3)处理达到39.31%和38.28%.高播种量处理下,土壤饱和持水量与毛管持水量显著提升(P<0.05),在高施肥高播量(F3S3)处理下最高分别为91.14%和81.39%.土壤养分特性方面,中高施肥处理有机质平均增加26.23%,pH值平均降至 7.5,呈中性偏碱.且随着施肥量的增加氮、磷、钾等关键养分显著提升(P<0.05).选取测定的植物和土壤指标进行灰色关联度和熵权TOPSIS分析,结果显示,中施肥高播量(F2S3)的恢复方案在生态效益和经济效益上具有双重优势.综上所述,本研究认为中施肥高播量(F2S3),即采用羊板粪330 m3·hm-2、有机肥15 t·hm-2、牧草专用肥150 kg·hm-2 以及播种量180 kg·hm-2 的恢复方案可作为青海省木里矿区生态恢复的优先参考方案.
Effects of different fertilization and sowing amounts on vegetation restoration and soil quality in alpine mining areas and comprehensive evaluation
The Muli coal mining area is located in the hinterland of the Qilian Mountains on the Qinghai-Tibet Plateau.After years of mining activity,excessive open-pit mining activities have encroached on swampy wetlands and a large amount of waste residue from mining has been landfilled.Soil affected by mining activity is infertile,which leads to difficulties in environmental restoration and high restoration costs.Therefore,it is crucial to conduct experiments to identify an efficient and low-cost ecological restoration plan.The experiment conducted forms part of a large-scale restoration program in Qinghai Province and comprised two-factors(fertilization and seeding rates),and three-levels of each.Specifically,the fertilization rates were:low fertilization,F1(sheep manure 165 m3·ha-1+organic fertilizer 7.5 t·ha-1+forage special fertilizer 75 kg·ha-1);medium fertilization,F2(sheep manure 330 m3·ha-1+organic fertilizer 15 t·ha-1+forage special fertilizer 150 kg·ha-1);and high fertilization,F3(sheep manure 495 m3·ha-1+organic fertilizer 22.5 t·ha-1+forage special fertilizer 225 kg·ha-1).The three seeding rates were:low seeding rate,S1(60 kg·ha-1);medium seeding rate,S2(120 kg·ha-1);and high seeding rate,S3(180 kg·ha-1).A total of nine restoration treatments were formed from the combinations of the three levels of fertilization and seeding rate,namely:low fertilization and low seeding rate(F1S1),low fertilization and medium seeding rate(F1S2),low fertilization and high seeding rate(F1S3),medium fertilization and low seeding rate(F2S1),medium fertilization and medium seeding rate(F2S2),medium fertilization and high seeding rate(F2S3),high fertilization and low seeding rate(F3S1),high fertilization and medium seeding rate(F3S2),and high fertilization and high seeding rate(F3S3).This experiment design therefore comprehensively evaluated the overall effectiveness of different restoration programs by exploring vegetation growth and soil quality changes in mining areas under various restoration treatments.Data were analyzed using grey relational analysis and the entropy weight TOPSIS method.The study results indicate that applying fertilizer and adjusting seeding rates significantly enhances vegetation restoration in the mining area(P<0.05).With medium and high fertilization treatments,vegetation cover exceeded 70%,vegetation density reached 8826-10447 plants·m-2,and aboveground biomass significantly increased to 445.51-559.47 g·m-2.Some restoration treatments also improved soil physical properties significantly(P<0.05).With medium and high fertilization treatments,soil bulk density averaged 0.94 g·cm-3.Moreover,increased fertilizer application led to a significant increase in soil moisture content,which reached 39.31%and 38.28%under F3S2 and F2S3,respectively.Soil saturated capacity and capillary water holding capacity also increased significantly(P<0.05)under high seeding rate treatments,with the highest values of 91.14%and 81.39%,respectively,under the F3S3 treatment.In terms of soil nutrient characteristics,medium and high fertilization treatments increased organic matter by an average of 26.23%,and the pH value averaged 7.5,indicating a slightly alkaline soil.Additionally,essential nutrients such as nitrogen,phosphorus,and potassium increased significantly with increasing fertilization(P<0.05).Through measured plant and soil indicators,grey relational analysis,and entropy weight TOPSIS analysis,it is evident that the restoration program with medium fertilization and high seeding rate(F2S3)offers dual advantages in both ecological and economic benefits.In conclusion,this study finds that 330 m3·ha-1 sheep manure,15 t·ha-1 organic fertilizer,150 kg·ha-1 specialized forage fertilizer,and a seeding rate of 180 kg·ha-1 in the Muli mining area of Qinghai Province can be recommended as the optimal combination for ecological restoration.

ecological restorationvegetation growthsoil nutrient characteristicsentropy weight TOPSIS analysisgrey relational degree analysis

刘文谨、蒋福祯、祁凯斌、宋明丹、李正鹏

展开 >

青海大学农林科学院,青海 西宁 810016

生态修复 植被生长 土壤养分特征 熵权TOPSIS分析 灰色关联度分析

2025

草业学报
中国草原学会 兰州大学草地农业科技学院

草业学报

影响因子:4.082
ISSN:1004-5759
年,卷(期):2025.34(5)