首页|开放科学背景下开放同行评议模式体系及协同运行机理

开放科学背景下开放同行评议模式体系及协同运行机理

扫码查看
结合文献调查、网络调查、案例分析,以主导主体作为首要划分标准,归纳开放同行评议模式,并基于协同理论从开放主体、开放形式、开放流程三方面剖析不同模式协同运行机理.现行开放同行评议模式可归纳为传统学术期刊、预印本平台、开放出版平台、开放评议社区四大类,根据各类别实践特点进一步细分为10种子模式.不同模式涉及不同的主体、形式、流程,其协同机理各异,学术共同体应结合各自需求与发展目标选择合适的评议模式并规范协同运行机制.
Model System and Collaborative Operating Mechanism of Open Peer Review in the Context of Open Science
Through a combination of literature reviews,online surveys,and case analyses,this study classifies open peer review models based on the leading entities as the primary criterion.Utilizing synergy theory,the paper categorizes open peer review models and analyzes the collaborative operation mechanisms from three aspects:open entities,open forms,and open processes.The existing open peer review models can be categorized into four major types:traditional academic journals,preprint platforms,open publishing platforms,and open review communities.Further subtypes are derived based on the specific characteristics of each category,resulting in a total of 10 sub-models.These diverse models involve different entities,forms,and processes,each with distinct collaborative mechanisms.Academic communities should choose an appropriate review model and standardize collaborative operation mechanisms based on their specific needs and development goals.

Open scienceOpen peer reviewModel systemSynergy theoryCollaborative operation

曾粤亮、乔雨杉、郑汉

展开 >

华中师范大学信息管理学院,武汉,430079

武汉大学信息管理学院,武汉,430072

开放科学 开放同行评议 模式体系 协同理论 协同运行

ISTIC-Spring Nature开放科学联合实验室开放基金

IT2227

2024

出版科学
湖北省编辑学会

出版科学

CSSCICHSSCD北大核心
影响因子:0.562
ISSN:1009-5853
年,卷(期):2024.32(1)
  • 58