首页|《中国足球协会纪律准则》裁量规范性水平的实证研究:以球员在比赛中违纪为例

《中国足球协会纪律准则》裁量规范性水平的实证研究:以球员在比赛中违纪为例

扫码查看
《中国足球协会纪律准则》使用至今已基本实现了文本的规范性,需要进一步关注其应用过程中的裁量规范性.通过对裁量原则、裁量程序和裁量情节三方面的现实考量,选取了裁量过程中的14个影响因素,并以2011—2023年间球员在比赛中违纪的568个案例为样本进行实证检验,发现:裁量规范性水平整体较好,但存在引用条款不恰当、理论与实际不统一、计算方式不严谨、文本更新不及时及疑似不规范的情况.为进一步提高裁量规范性水平,建议从实现教育功能、明晰条款适用、规制裁量权行使3个方面加以改进,通过规范行使体育协会管理职能为中国足球事业发展奠定坚实基础.
The Empirical Study on the Normative Level of Discretion in the CFA Disciplinary Regulations: Taking Misconduct of Players in Games as an Example
The CFA Disciplinary Regulations has basically realized the standardization of law documents so far, and further atten-tion needs to be paid to the standardization of discretion in the process of application. Through the realistic consideration of discretion principle, process and circumstances, 14 influencing factors of discretions were selected, and 568 cases of players' misconduct in games during 2011-2023 seasons were taken as samples for empirical testing. It is found that the overall standard level of discretions is good, but there are inappropriate citation provisions, disunity of theory and practice, unscientific calculation methods, untimely text updates and suspected non-standard discretions. In order to further improve the standard level of discretions, it is suggested that it should be improved from three aspects: realizing the educational function, clarifying the application of provisions and regulating the work of discretion, so as to lay a solid foundation for the development of Chinese football by standardizing the management function of sports associations.

the CFA Disciplinary Regulationsthe normative level of discretiondiscretionary powerfootballsports law

傅启浩、曹金容

展开 >

华东政法大学 政府管理学院,上海201620

四川师范大学 纪检监察学院,四川 成都610068

《中国足球协会纪律准则》 裁量规范 自由裁量权 足球 体育法

国家社会科学基金一般项目

20BTY055

2024

成都体育学院学报
成都体育学院

成都体育学院学报

CSTPCDCSSCICHSSCD北大核心
影响因子:1.053
ISSN:1001-9154
年,卷(期):2024.50(2)
  • 25