首页|规划协作实现空间共享的成效:广州市175个社区小型足球场规划的实证

规划协作实现空间共享的成效:广州市175个社区小型足球场规划的实证

扫码查看
通过规划干预实现空间资源共享是响应"共享发展"理念的重要抓手.大量实践研究认为规划协作能实现良好结果,理论构建中也发现了规划协作实现空间共享的明确路径.但现实当中,原创设计无需协作也令人满意、协作顺畅却共享失败的例子也比比皆是,如何检验规划协作实现空间共享的机制与成效仍缺乏研究.以广州市社区小型足球场规划的175个选址为样本,开展相同制度政策条件下不同规划协作程度实现空间共享成效的实证研究.通过规划参与过程与实施结果回访的论述,逻辑回归模型开展定量分析,初步论证以规划协作实现空间共享的稳健机制、相对成效与作用边界.结果表明协作完成度越高、共享实现的可能性越大.规划协作能有效破解用地产权限制、场地现状与目标存在差异的阻力,但也发现后发事件作为外部影响因素具有推翻协作成果的影响.研究为存量时代的详细规划实施提供了一种新的理论启发和实证支持.
Effectiveness of Space Sharing Through Collaborative Planning:A Study of 175 Cases of Community Football Field Planning in Guangzhou
The concept of"shared development"promotes space sharing through plan-ning interventions.While empirical studies commonly suggest that collaborative plan-ning leads to positive outcomes in space sharing,practical experiences demonstrate that independent efforts can also yield satisfactory results,and collaborative endeav-ors may fail to achieve sharing goals.The effectiveness of collaborative planning mechanisms for achieving space sharing remains underexplored in the existing schol-arship.Through examining 175 sites selected in the Community Football Fields Plan in Guangzhou,the paper explores the effectiveness of space sharing through collab-orative planning within the same institutional framework.Based on survey data on participatory processes and implementation results,a preliminary logistic regression model is used to quantitatively assess the relationships between the strength of par-ticipatory mechanisms,relative effectiveness,and boundary of space sharing achieved through collaborative planning.The findings support the hypothesis that as collabora-tive planning becomes more comprehensive,the likelihood of establishing stable and enduring space sharing significantly improves.Notably,the P-value and OR-value of collaborative efforts levels indicates that collaboration can effectively address various challenges,such as land-use right constraints and discrepancies between current situa-tions and land-use goals.Additionally,the study notes that external factors,repre-sented by subsequent events,can influence and even overturn outcomes achieved through collaborative efforts.The study provides new theoretical inspirations and em-pirical support for detailed planning and implementation in the era of urban regenera-tion.

detailed planningexisting land stock developmentcollaborative plan-ningspace sharingplanning effectiveness

黎子铭、王世福、邓兴栋

展开 >

华南理工大学建筑学院

广州市城市规划勘测设计研究院

广州市城市规划勘测设计研究院创新中心

广东省城乡高质量发展研究中心

国务院

展开 >

详细规划 存量开发 规划协作 空间共享 规划成效

国家社会科学基金重大研究专项

22VHQ009

2024

城市规划学刊
同济大学

城市规划学刊

CSTPCDCSSCICHSSCD北大核心
影响因子:3.822
ISSN:1000-3363
年,卷(期):2024.(2)
  • 48