首页|论小资产阶级文艺的论争与批判——从许杰的《小资产阶级与文艺》一文说起

论小资产阶级文艺的论争与批判——从许杰的《小资产阶级与文艺》一文说起

扫码查看
1957年8月,叶以群、孔罗荪、姚文元合作撰文《许杰在文艺上政治上的反动道路》,其中叶以群的《许杰的"小资产阶级文艺"之旗》,直接批判许杰1948年发表的《小资产阶级与文艺》。1928年的革命文学倡导,开启了以阶级划分作家、以小资产阶级界定作家与创作的先声。在与梁实秋的人性论、"自由人"、"第三种人"的论争中,常常将他们归为小资产阶级文人,成为找不到政治出路动摇者的标签。1942年延安文艺座谈会后,知识分子的思想改造被确定了,小资产阶级的自我反省和批判被突出了。在中国现代文学史中,常常以小资产阶级作为评判作家创作的不足和短处。在历次对于小资产阶级文人和创作的批判针砭过程中,将阶级斗争观念作为衡量作家衡量文学的标准,忽略与抛弃了人性与文学的复杂性和丰富性;将革命与否视作评判作家立场与情感的唯一标准,模糊与消弭文学与革命不同的视阈及文学的特性;将工农兵的立场和情感看作衡量作家和文学的标准,批评或否定了文学表达的多样性与先锋性。
Controversy and Criticism of Petite Bourgeoisie Literature and Art:Based on Xu Jie's"Petty Bourgeoisie and Literature and Art"
In August 1957,Ye Yiqun,Kong Luosun and Yao Wenyuan co-wrote a paper entitled"Xu Jie's Reactionary Road in Literature and Art and Politics",and then Ye Yiqun's wrote"The Banner of Xu Jie's'Petite Bourgeoisie Literature and Art'",which directly criticized Xu Jie's"Petty Bourgeoisie and Literature and Art"published in 1948.In 1928,the revolutionary literature took the first step of dividing writers by class and defining writers and creation by petite bourgeoisie.In the debates with Liang Shiqiu on the theory of human nature,"free man"and"the third kind of person",they were often classified as petite bourgeoisie men of letters,a label for vacillators who failed to find a political way out.After the Yan'an forum on literature and art in 1942,the ideological transformation of the intellectuals was confirmed,and the self-reflection and criticism of the petite bourgeoisie were highlighted.In the history of modern literature,petite bourgeoisie was often used to judge the shortcomings of writers'works.In the course of criticizing the petite bourgeoisie writers and their works,the concept of class struggle was adopted as the standard to measure literature,ignoring and discarding the complexity and richness of human nature and literature;revolution was regarded as the only criterion to judge the writer's position and emotion,blurring and eliminating the different visual thresholds and literary characteristics of literature and revolution;and the position and emotion of workers,peasants and soldiers were used as the standard to measure writers and literature,criticizing or negating the diversity and avant-garde character of literary expression.

Xu Jie"Petty Bourgeoisie and Literature and Art"petite bourgeoisiecontroversycriticism

杨剑龙

展开 >

上海师范大学人文学院,上海 200233

许杰 《小资产阶级与文艺》 小资产阶级 论争 批判

国家社会科学基金重大项目上海高水平大学中国语言文学创新团队项目

16ZDA188

2024

东方论坛
青岛大学

东方论坛

CHSSCD
影响因子:0.116
ISSN:1005-7110
年,卷(期):2024.(2)
  • 97