电子知识产权2024,Issue(11) :75-88.

"弱显著性商标"概念辨析及其侵权判定

Discrimination of the Concept of Weakly Distinctive Trademark and the Determination of Infringement

刘义军
电子知识产权2024,Issue(11) :75-88.

"弱显著性商标"概念辨析及其侵权判定

Discrimination of the Concept of Weakly Distinctive Trademark and the Determination of Infringement

刘义军1
扫码查看

作者信息

  • 1. 北京市西城区人民法院
  • 折叠

摘要

"弱显著性商标"主要包括暗示商标、描述商标、含有描述性要素或地名等公共领域元素的商标、显著性退化的商标等.比例原则要求适当限缩"弱显著性商标"的禁用权范围."弱显著性商标"权利人无权禁止他人正当使用商标中包含的描述标志、地名及其他公共领域元素.商标显著性逐渐退化后,其保护范围和强度应相应缩减.商标法亦应为"弱显著性商标"权利人规范使用该商标预留充足空间.法院在审理涉"弱显著性商标"侵权案件时应主要考量被告对相关标志的使用是否构成商标性使用,原告的"弱显著性商标"专用权效力是否稳定及其知名度,其显著性强弱对商标近似、商品类似判断的影响,被告使用相关标志的行为是否具有恶意等因素.反向混淆是否成立和商标的显著性程度存在密切关系,在权利商标固有显著性较弱的情况下,除非被告使用相关标志的行为具有明显恶意,否则法院应更倾向于认定反向混淆不成立.

Abstract

Weakly distinctive trademarks mainly include suggestive trademarks,descriptive trademarks,trademarks containing descriptive elements or public domain elements such as place names,trademarks with degraded distinctiveness,etc.The principle of proportionality requires that the scope of the right to prohibit weakly distinctive trademarks be appropriately limited.The owner of weakly distinctive trademarks has no right to prohibit others from properly using the descriptive marks,place names and other public domain elements contained in the trademark.When the distinctiveness of a trademark gradually deteriorates,the scope and intensity of its protection should be reduced accordingly;the trademark law should also reserve sufficient space for the rights holder of a weakly distinctive trademark to regulate the use of the trademark.In infringement cases,the main considerations should be whether the defendant's use of the relevant marks constitutes trademark use,whether the plaintiff's exclusive right to use the weakly distinctive mark is stable and well-known,and whether its distinctiveness determines whether the trademark is similar or the goods are similar.Whether the defendant's use of relevant marks is malicious and other factors are closely related to the distinctiveness of the trademark.In the case where the inherent distinctiveness of the right trademark is weak,unless the defendant uses the relevant marks.The behavior is obviously malicious,otherwise the court is more likely to find that reverse confusion is not established.

关键词

弱显著性商标/商标知名度/比例原则/公共领域元素/反向混淆

Key words

Weakly Distinctive Trademark/Trademark Reputation/Principle of Proportionality/Public Domain Elements/Reverse Confusion

引用本文复制引用

出版年

2024
电子知识产权
工业和信息化部电子科技情报研究所 工业和信息化部电子知识产权中心

电子知识产权

CHSSCD
影响因子:0.465
ISSN:1004-9517
段落导航相关论文