首页|网络谣言刑事治理的理念、路径与方案

网络谣言刑事治理的理念、路径与方案

扫码查看
相比于传统谣言,网络谣言的危害性并未明显增加,刑法介入网络谣言治理时应当保持理性和克制。网络谣言作为信息的载体,具有多重面向,刑法治理的谣言应当具备内容虚假性、内容系事实性言论、与现实生活存在紧密关联三个特征。我国《刑法》已经构建起系统性治理网络谣言的体系,但在具体适用中应当从以下两方面平衡刑法的社会保护与人权保障功能:在宏观层面上,应当树立刑法不应过度介入言论犯罪的理念;在微观层面上,可以建立区分公共法益和个体法益分级保护的刑法模式,强化刑法对个体法益的刑法保护。网络空间的秩序特征在于实现了不同现实空间的线上互联,对于仅在网络上散布谣言,未引起现实空间秩序混乱的行为,不属于刑法治理的行为。对于网络谣言传播行为进行刑法治理时,传谣者的主观明知应达到"确实知道"的程度,且网络谣言已经被证伪后的传播行为因为不具有实质危害性,不宜轻易入罪。
Compared with traditional rumors,the harm of online rumors has not increased dramatically,therefore the criminal law should maintain rationality and restraint when regulating online rumors.Online rumors,as information carrier,have multiple aspects.Correspondingly,rumors regulated by criminal law should have three characteristics,which are false content,factual speech,and a close connection to real life.Chinese criminal law has built a system to comprehensively reg-ulate online rumors,but in specific applications,it should balance the social protection and human rights protection func-tions of the criminal law from the following two aspects.At the macro level,the idea that criminal law should not excessive-ly criminalize speech has to be established;At the micro level,criminal protection towards public interests and individual interests should be distinguished and the latter should be enhanced.One feature of cyber space,namely the order of it,makes the interconnection of different real spaces possible.Spreading rumors on the internet without causing chaos in the real space does not fall in the regulation of criminal law.When criminalizing the dissemination of online rumors,the sub-jective knowledge of the rumor spreaders should reach the level of"really have known",and the dissemination behavior af-ter the online rumors have been falsified is not materially harmful and should not be readily criminalized.

online rumorscriminal governancecyber spacepublic legal interest

陈庆安

展开 >

上海社会科学院法学研究所,上海 200216

网络谣言 刑法治理 网络空间 公共法益

国家社会科学基金一般项目司法部法治建设与法学理论研究专项

22BFX17620SFB4029

2024

法律科学-西北政法大学学报
西北政法大学

法律科学-西北政法大学学报

CSTPCDCSSCICHSSCD北大核心
影响因子:2.096
ISSN:1674-5205
年,卷(期):2024.42(3)