首页|公私法融合视角下强制性环境标准之环境侵权效力重构

公私法融合视角下强制性环境标准之环境侵权效力重构

扫码查看
强制性环境标准的环境侵权效力在国内外法学理论与司法实践领域一直存在争议.强调受害者利益保护的私法视角倾向于否认强制性环境标准具有阻却环境侵权责任的法律效力,而强调合理规制环境风险的公法视角倾向于承认强制性环境标准具有阻却环境侵权责任的法律效力.但是,仅仅从私法视角或公法视角审视和解答强制性环境标准的环境侵权效力问题,都存在不足.强制性环境标准的环境侵权效力在本质上是一个公私法交叉问题,应当从公私法融合的视角,对其进行类型化重构.环境质量标准能否阻却环境侵权受害者的索赔请求,取决于受害者所受损害是否属于环境质量标准所保护的对象范围.污染物排放标准能否阻却污染者对环境侵权受害者承担侵权责任,应根据污染物属于累积性污染物还是非累积性污染物和排污行为受环保行政规制程度的强弱而定.
Reconstruction of Tort Law Effectiveness of Mandatory Environmental Standards From the Perspective of Integration of Public and Private Law
The tort effectiveness of mandatory environmental standards has been controversial in the field of legal theory and judi-cial practice at both china and abroad.The perspective of private law that emphasizes the protection of victims'interests tends to deny that mandatory environmental standards have the legal effect of preventing environmental tort liability,while the perspective of public law that emphasizes reasonable regulation of environmental risks tends to admit that mandatory environmental standards have the legal effect of preventing environmental tort liability.However,only from the perspective of private law or public law to examine and solve the tort law effectiveness of mandatory environmental standards has serious deficiencies.In essence,the effect of tort law on mandatory environmental standards is an intersection of public and private law,which should be reconstructed from the perspective of public and private law fusion.Whether the environmental quality standard can prevent the victim's claim de-pends on whether the victim's damage falls within the scope of the object protected by the environmental quality standard.Wheth-er pollutant emission standards can prevent polluters from bearing tort liability to victims depends on whether pollutants are cumu-lative pollutants or non-cumulative pollutants and the degree of environmental protection administrative regulations.

environmental quality standardpollutant emission standardsenvironmental regulationenvironmental tort

刘卫先、杜雅馨

展开 >

中国海洋大学法学院,山东青岛 266100

环境质量标准 污染物排放标准 环境规制 环境侵权

国家社科基金一般项目

17BFX121

2024

法学论坛
山东省法学会

法学论坛

CSTPCDCSSCICHSSCD北大核心
影响因子:1.873
ISSN:1009-8003
年,卷(期):2024.39(4)