首页|公司分配视角下的股东身份从属债权劣后受偿

公司分配视角下的股东身份从属债权劣后受偿

扫码查看
股东身份从属债权系股权转化成立的特殊股东债权,包括由股权固有内容具象而生的债权和非典型股权融资协议下依附于股权的债权.因与股权具有内在同一性,该类债权应劣后于普通债权受偿.某些债权虽非股权的转化,因债权人实际地位类似于股东,亦得比照适用而劣后.股东身份从属债权劣后受偿能阻却公司经营风险的事后再分配与股东权利顺位的自行提升,为股债关联现象引发的公司分配难题提供更自洽的注解.基于该规则,可重廓公司分配制度的内在体系.资本维持原则和偿债能力标准仅关乎以股东与公司间不当利益转移的规制间接维护债权优先顺位,作用分别限于防范股东自公司获得不应有的法定权益性分配,以及股东与公司间交易有失公允而损及公司偿债能力.股东身份从属债权劣后受偿规则在权益性分配之债依法或依约成立时,避免因"股转债"造成股东与公司债权人间的事后风险不当分配.
Shareholders'status-accessory claims(SSACs)are derivatives of equity,including claims a-rising from the inherent content of equity and claims dependent on equity under equity-debt hybrid finan-cing agreements.Because of their intrinsic identity with equity,SSACs should be subordinated to gener-al claims.Certain claims,although are not derivatives of equity,may also be subordinated since the holders'status is similar to that of shareholders.The subordination of SSACs can prevent the redistribu-tion of a company's business risks and the bootstrap of shareholders'rights,providing a more self-con-sistent explanation for corporate distribution issues caused by the hybrid of debt and equity.Based on this subordination rule,the inner system of corporate distribution can be reconstructed.The capital ma-intenance principle and the solvency test only involve indirect preservation of the priority of claims by regulating improper transfers of interests between shareholders and the company,with the effect of pre-venting shareholders from receiving undeserved legal payments from the company and preventing unfair transactions between shareholders and the company from jeopardizing its solvency,respectively.The subordination of SSACs prevents the misallocation of risks between shareholders and creditors of a com-pany resulting from the"conversion from equity into debt"when the debt for the distribution of owners'equity is established by law or by contract.

corporate distributioncapital maintenancesolvencysubordinated claimsVAM agree-ment

何欢

展开 >

上海财经大学法学院

公司分配 资本维持 偿债能力 劣后债权 对赌协议

2023年度上海市哲学社会科学规划课题

2023BFX009

2024

法学研究
中国社会科学院法学研究所

法学研究

CSTPCDCSSCICHSSCD北大核心
影响因子:4.419
ISSN:1002-896X
年,卷(期):2024.46(1)
  • 10