首页|"好差评"制度提高在线政务服务效能了吗?——基于自然实验和断点回归的实证检验

"好差评"制度提高在线政务服务效能了吗?——基于自然实验和断点回归的实证检验

扫码查看
政务服务"好差评"制度是党的十八大以来备受关注、被寄予厚望的重要改革措施之一,其政策效果和优化方向也受到了学术界的广泛关注.地方领导留言板是网上干群互动平台,作为在线政务服务的缩影,于2019 年6 月开通满意度评价功能,可以作为"好差评"制度政策效果的自然实验研究场景.本文利用平台开通满意度评价功能的外生性,采用深度机器学习方法分析了2.7 万余条干群互动文本特征,测量在线政务服务效能及相关研究变量,使用断点回归模型估计了网民满意度评价对在线政务服务效能的影响作用.研究结果与预期相同,网民满意度评价对提高政府在线服务效能起到决定性作用,但是不同地方政府在线政务服务效能提升的程度及显著性有一定差异,论文进一步分析了可能原因.采用不同估计方法、模型设定、带宽选择,研究结果均有很强的稳健性.研究结论有助于深化对"好差评"制度的认识,也有助于理解这一制度实施过程中需要优化的关键问题.
Did the Government Service Rating System Improve the Effectiveness of Online Government Services?—Empirical Tests Based on a Natural Experiment Using Regression Discontinuity Design
Implementing the"Good/Poor Rating System"for government services is one of the reform measures that have received great attention and expectation since the 18th National Congress of the Communist Party of China.The policy effect of this reform and its opti-mization direction has gained extensive attention from academia.The Message Board for Leaders on People's Daily is an online political deliberation platform.As the epitome of online government services,the Message Board for Leaders added the satisfaction rating function in June 2019,which became the natural intervention of the"Good/Poor"rating system.Using the exogeneity of the satisfaction rating function,this paper applies deep learning methods to analyze the textual features of more than 27,000 netizens'posts and government responses and measures the effectiveness of online government service and related variables.This paper estimates the impact of netizens'satisfaction ratings on the effectiveness of online government service with regression discontinuity design.As expected,the netizens'sat-isfaction ratings play a decisive role in improving the effectiveness of government online services.Also,the positive impacts vary in de-gree and statistical significance among different local governments.The results remain robust with different estimation methods,model settings,and bandwidth selections.The conclusion of this study deepens the understanding of the"Good/Poor Rating System"and sheds light on the key issues that should be optimized.

the effectiveness of online government services"good/poor rating system"public satisfaction

王天梅、赵钰宁、于鹏、朱艳春

展开 >

中央财经大学信息学院,北京 102200

中央财经大学政府管理学院,北京 100081

北京师范大学经济与工商管理学院,北京 100875

在线政务服务效能 "好差评"制度 公众满意度

国家重点研发计划国家自然科学基金面上项目北京社会科学基金研究基地一般项目

2021YFF09008007207219418JDGLB020

2024

管理评论
中国科学院研究生院

管理评论

CSTPCDCSSCICHSSCD北大核心
影响因子:1.801
ISSN:1003-1952
年,卷(期):2024.36(1)
  • 49