首页|国有企业如何管理组织身份模糊?——基于南星的纵向案例研究

国有企业如何管理组织身份模糊?——基于南星的纵向案例研究

扫码查看
国有企业是中国经济发展的顶梁柱,"国有"性质决定其具有高度制度依赖性,组织内部需要维持身份模糊状态以适应高度不确定的制度环境变化.本文采用案例研究方法,分析了一家国有企业2004-2021 年的身份模糊管理过程,研究发现,身份模糊以不同的状态存在于国有企业之中,呈现出"不透明→手段模糊→多歧义→边界模糊"的演化路径,管理者与组织成员的互动是推动身份模糊状态演变的动力机制.其中,高层管理者采取的策略包括激活裂变、选择性回应、构建反身份和情感共鸣;组织成员的反应包括审视自我、群体分化、群内区隔和情感认同.身份模糊经过管理者的有效引导发挥着吸引参与身份讨论、构造内部协商空间、合理限定解释范围以及塑造跨界融合特性的积极作用.本研究采用内部视角研究国有企业身份变革的过程,对现有从外部合法性视角开展的研究形成了有效补充,同时丰富了关于身份模糊积极面的研究,为理解国有企业组织身份变革、促进其高质量发展提供了理论洞见和实践启示.
How to Manage Organizational Identity Ambiguity in State-owned Enterprises?—A Longitudinal Case Study Based on Nanxing
State-owned enterprises(SOEs)are the backbone of China's economic development.The"state-owned"nature of these en-terprises imbues them with a high degree of institutional dependency,necessitating the maintenance of an ambiguous organizational iden-tity to adapt to the highly uncertain changes in the institutional environment.This paper employs a case study methodology to analyze the identity ambiguity management process of a state-owned enterprise from 2004 to 2021.The study finds that identity ambiguity exists in va-rious states within SOEs,following an evolutionary path from"opacity→means ambiguity→multivocality→boundary ambiguity."The in-teraction between managers and organizational members acts as a driving mechanism for the evolution of states of identity ambiguity.The strategies adopted by senior managers include activating fission,selective response,constructing counter-identities,and emotional reso-nance,whereas the reactions of organizational members encompass self-examination,group differentiation,intra-group segmentation,and emotional identification.Through effective guidance by managers,identity ambiguity plays a positive role in attracting participation in identity discussions,constructing internal negotiation spaces,reasonably limiting the scope of interpretation,and shaping cross-boundary integration characteristics.By adopting an internal perspective to study the process of identity change in state-owned enterprises,this re-search serves as an effective complement to existing studies that have been conducted from an external legitimacy perspective.It also enri-ches the research on the positive aspects of identity ambiguity,providing theoretical insights and practical implications for understanding the organizational identity transformation of SOEs and promoting their high-quality development.

organizational identity ambiguitytop managementinternal organizational conflictstate-owned enterprises(SOEs)case study

肖咪咪、黄菲菲、贾良定

展开 >

南京理工大学经济管理学院,南京 210094

南京大学商学院,南京 210093

组织身份模糊 高层管理者 组织内部冲突 国有企业 案例研究

国家自然科学基金面上项目

72372068

2024

管理评论
中国科学院研究生院

管理评论

CSTPCDCSSCICHSSCD北大核心
影响因子:1.801
ISSN:1003-1952
年,卷(期):2024.36(7)
  • 15