首页|基于指标比值的交叉DDF投影点效率评价方法

基于指标比值的交叉DDF投影点效率评价方法

扫码查看
为解决传统DEA和DDF存在的问题,学者们提出交叉DDF,但现有交叉DDF仍存在一些问题:因忽略指标松弛量导致评价结果不精准;决策单元之间的评价基准(参照点)不一致;可能存在多个最优解;无法实现决策单元的效率全排序.为解决以上问题,本文给出基于指标比值的交叉DDF投影点效率评价方法.首先给出基于参照点的相对效率定义,即决策单元相对于参照点的综合投入指标比率和综合产出指标比率的比值,这样能将决策单元指标的所有信息考虑到效率评价中;其次,构建以最小化松弛量之和为第二目标函数的DDF模型,以尽可能得到决策单元唯一的投影点和评价结果;最后,以DDF投影点为参照,根据相对效率定义对决策单元进行交叉评价,使得评价参照点一致,评价结果不受方向向量长度影响且共识性强,同时实现决策单元的效率全排序.算例说明该方法具有一定的科学性和可行性.
Crossing Efficiency Evaluation Method through DDF Projections According to Indicator Ratios
To solve the problems of the traditional data envelopment analysis(DEA)and directional distance function(DDF),scholars have proposed crossing DDF methods,but those methods are still defective in that evaluation results are inaccurate for the slacks of indi-cators being neglected;evaluation benchmarks(reference points)are inconsistent among DMUs;there may be multiple optimal solu-tions;and the efficiency of decision-making units cannot be fully ranked.In order to solve the above defects,this paper gives a cross effi-ciency evaluation method through DDF projections according to the indicator ratios between two DMUs.Firstly,this method gives the def-inition of relative efficiency based on reference DMUs,i.e.,the ratio of comprehensive input ratio and comprehensive output ratio of DMUs,and makes all indicators'information of DMUs to be taken into account in efficiency evaluation.Secondly,based on the DDF method,the second objective function model that minimizes the sum of the slacks of inputs and outputs is constructed to obtain unique projection and unique evaluation result for DMUs.Finally,taking the DDF projections as references,the crossing efficiency of DMUs is evaluated according to the definition of relative efficiency,which ensures that evaluation reference points are consistent among the DMUs,evaluation results are not affected by the length of direction vectors and have strong consensus,and all DMUs are fully ranked according to their efficiencies.Two numerical examples are used to show that to a certain extent,the proposed method is scientific and feasible.

DEADDFindicator ratioprojectioncrossing-evaluation

王庆、孟海宁、武华琛、李岸达

展开 >

天津商业大学管理学院,天津 300134

天津商业大学管理创新与评价研究中心,天津 300134

DEA DDF 指标比值 投影点 交叉评价

2024

管理评论
中国科学院研究生院

管理评论

CSTPCDCSSCICHSSCD北大核心
影响因子:1.801
ISSN:1003-1952
年,卷(期):2024.36(8)