首页|恩义终难断:传统中国的"大义灭亲"——以"石碏杀子"案及历代评析为中心

恩义终难断:传统中国的"大义灭亲"——以"石碏杀子"案及历代评析为中心

扫码查看
传统中国存在很多"大义灭亲"行为,《左传》记载的"石碏杀子"为其"祖述"案例.历代君相、文人士夫针对此案,结合各自所处的时势,从策略、居心到影响所及的风俗,有褒贬悬殊的评判."大义灭亲"正当性之小大一则取决于"灭"与"被灭"者之间的伦常尊卑关系;二则取决于该行为所欲成就之"大义"的内容.随着君主专制的强化并最终趋于独裁之势,君臣大义几获垄断地位.即便如此,因大义灭亲"残骨肉""陷良臣""杀子孙""害兄弟",始终未获得充足的正当性,盖人于天地之间,恩义终难断.
En and Yi Are Hard to Sever after All:Traditional China's"dà yì miè qīn":Centering on the Case"Shi Que Killed His Son"and Its Commentaries
In traditional China,there are numerous instances"placing righteousness above family loyalty"(dà yì miè qīn),"Shi Que killed his son"recorded in Zuo Zhuan is the first case they followed.Emperors and prime ministers as well as the literati and Scholar-bureaucrats in all dynasties,left commentaries on this case with great disparity between praise and criticism.The justification of such behavior depends on the ethical and hierarchical relationship between the person who carries out the act of ruining and his kin or intimate who is ruined,and also depends on the content of righteousness(dà yì)which the behavior aims to achieve.As the absolutism of monarchy strengthened and tended towards dictatorship,the principle of righteousness between emperor and ministers almost gains a monopoly."Damaging immediate relatives""undermining loyalists""killing sons and grandsons"and"harming brothers"for the sake of"dà yì miè qīn",however,still could not be completely justified.

traditional cultureethical and hierarchical relationshiprighteousness between the monarch and his ministers

李启成

展开 >

北京大学法学院

北京大学近代法研究所,100871

传统文化 伦常尊卑 君臣大义

国家社会科学基金一般项目

21BFX003

2024

国外社会科学
中国社会科学院信息情报研究院

国外社会科学

CSSCICHSSCD北大核心
影响因子:0.225
ISSN:1000-4777
年,卷(期):2024.(1)
  • 106