首页|美国著作权合理使用的规范建构与司法扩张

美国著作权合理使用的规范建构与司法扩张

扫码查看
著作权的限制与例外是各国著作权法的重要组成部分,美国的著作权合理使用因其开放式立法而成为一种独具特色的著作权限制.美国的合理使用规范经由1976年立法已成为制定法,但从法律渊源、规范构成、判例特征等方面考察,仍然应当属于普通法.合理使用规则通过判例法体系与立法修订而不断更新、灵活适用,因应当下由于科技与经济社会迅速发展所带来的新问题.美国法院采用"多要素分析方法"裁判合理使用案件,也出现了因过度倚重"转换性使用"而产生的司法扩张与制度性偏差.我国著作权法当前有关权利限制的条文过于简单,而通过借鉴与吸收国外先进经验,以法律的开放性结构来发挥合理使用制度的功能,有利于完善我国著作权法,实现其保护权利与促进创新的目标.
Construction and Judicial Expansion of Fair Use Doctrine in U.S.Copyright Law
Limitations and exceptions to the exclusive right are the important part of the copyright law around the world,and the fair use doctrine in the U.S.Copyright Act is a unique limitation with open structure.With the legislation of 1976 Act,the fair use doctrine has been modified,but it still belongs to the common law when considered from such aspects as the source of law,type of norms and characteristics of case law.What's more,the fair use doctrine has been interpreted and employed flexibly via case law system and legislative revisions,responding to new challenges brought by technological,social,and economic development.The U.S.courts employ"multiple factor test"to decide fair use case effectively,though there's institutional bias due to an over-reliance on some factors,especially the so-called"transformative use".The provisions on limitations to copyright in China's Copyright Law are a comparatively simplistic.Drawing on the open structure of fair use doctrine could help to improve China's copyright system,thereby achieving the goal of protecting copyright and promoting the innovation.

copyrightfair usedoctrinerule and standardAmerican law

金海军

展开 >

中国人民大学法学院 100872

著作权 合理使用 判例规则 规则与标准 美国

2024

国外社会科学
中国社会科学院信息情报研究院

国外社会科学

CSSCICHSSCD北大核心
影响因子:0.225
ISSN:1000-4777
年,卷(期):2024.(2)