首页|均衡与非均衡:"互惠"的人类学争论

均衡与非均衡:"互惠"的人类学争论

扫码查看
互惠是人类社会交往中普遍而重要的现象,也是人类学的重要理论课题.长期以来,人类学家偏重于强调互惠的均衡性.随着相关研究的深化和拓展,部分人类学家不仅注意到互惠往来中的非均衡现象,而且对占据主流地位的均衡互惠理论提出了挑战.肯定互惠往来中存在着非均衡性的学者反思了"互惠"概念本身,批判互惠研究背后隐含的"礼物—商品"二分法,关注不同社会文化中的回报缺失现象,并揭示了不平等的权力结构关系之下回报的差异性.在中国的社会文化语境中,若要全面考察互惠实践,不仅要关注均衡现象,亦不能忽略非均衡现象,并且应跳出西方人类学界过分强调个体关系的分析框架,把中国人的互惠实践放置在"情境"中加以理解.
BALANCE AND UNBALANCE:AN ANTHROPOLOGICAL DEBATE ON RECIPROCITY
Reciprocity is a common and important phenomenon in human social interaction,as well the impor-tant theoretical topic in anthropology.For a long time,anthropologists lay particular stress on emphasing the balance of reciprocity.With the deepening and expansion of relevant studies,some anthropologists not only notice the unbal-anced phenomenon of reciprocal intercations,but also challenge the theory of balanced reciprocity which holds the mainstream status.The anthropologists who confirm the existence of unbalance in reciprocal interactions reflect the concept of reciprocity itself,criticize the"Gift-Commodity"dichotomy connoted in the study of reciprocity,pay attention to the lack of return phenomenon in different social cultures,and reveal the differences of return in unequal power structures and relations.In the social and cultural context of China,if we want to examin reciprocity practices comprehensively,we not only need to pay attention to the balance phenomenon but also to the unbalance phenomenon,as well as to jump out of the analytical framework of overemphasized individual relationships by the Western anthropology,and to understand the reciprocal practices of Chinese people in the concrete"Context".

Reciprocityunbalancebalance

刘士缘、贾仲益

展开 >

中央民族大学民族学与社会学学院 北京,100081

互惠 非均衡 均衡

2024

广西民族研究
广西壮族自治区民族问题研究中心

广西民族研究

CSSCICHSSCD北大核心
影响因子:0.634
ISSN:1004-454X
年,卷(期):2024.(4)