首页|民营经济刑法保护的公平价值及其实现

民营经济刑法保护的公平价值及其实现

扫码查看
健全以公平为核心原则的产权保护制度,是强化民营经济发展的内在要求和法治保障。公平与平等、公正的含义存在差别,民营经济法治保障需要确立适应市场经济发展需求的公平价值观。我国刑事立法长期存在不同所有制经济的差异化保护问题,刑法修正逐步趋向民营经济与国有经济保护的均等化,但也存在均等但不公平的现象和问题。刑法保护民营经济发展,需要强化实质公平理念,克服均等化保护的缺陷,从而实现形式公平与实质公平的统一。形式公平要求不同所有制主体法律地位平等、民营企业产权受到公平保护和民营企业家权益得到有效保障。实质公平则要求司法机关针对不同所有制主体给予定罪处刑的差异化处遇。在将民营企业内部人员背信行为人罪化的同时,须通过实质解释限缩其入罪范围。另外,在针对涉民营企业腐败犯罪贯彻"受贿行贿一起查"政策过程中,也需要秉持实质公平观念,避免同等处罚,真正实现刑法的公平公正。
The Fair Value of Criminal Law Protection of Private Economy and its Realization
Improving the property rights protection system with equity as the core principle is the internal requirement and legal guarantee for strengthening the development of private economy.There are differences in the meaning of fairness,equality and justice,and the legal protection of private economy needs to establish fair values that meet the needs of market economy development.China's criminal legislation has long consisted of the problem of differentiated protection of different ownership economies,and the amendment of criminal law gradually tends to equalize the protection of private economy and state-owned economy,but there are also equal but unfair phenomena and problems.To protect the development of private economy,the criminal law needs to strengthen the concept of substantive justice and overcome the defect of equal protection,so as to realize the unity of formal justice and substantive justice.Formal fairness requires equal legal status of different ownership entities,fair protection of private enterprise property rights and effective protection of private entrepreneurs'rights and interests.Substantive fairness requires the judicial organs to give different treatments of conviction and punishment according to different ownership subjects.In the process of criminalizing breach of trust by internal personnel in private enterprises,the scope of crime should be limited by substantive interpretation.In addition,in the process of implementing the policy of"investigating bribe-taking and bribery together"for corruption crimes involving private enterprises,it is also necessary to uphold the concept of substantive fairness,avoid equal penalties,and truly realize the fairness and justice of criminal law.

private economycriminal law protectionfair valuesubstantive equity

张勇、郏梦蝶

展开 >

华东政法大学刑事法学院,上海 200042

民营经济 刑法保护 公平价值 实质公平

国家社会科学基金一般项目

23BFX116

2024

河北法学
河北政法职业学院 河北省法学会

河北法学

CHSSCD北大核心
影响因子:0.992
ISSN:1002-3933
年,卷(期):2024.42(4)
  • 52