首页|执纪执法指导性案例的法治逻辑及制度优化

执纪执法指导性案例的法治逻辑及制度优化

扫码查看
执纪执法指导性案例的指导功能包括解释性、统一性和自控性三重维度,由此其承载着有限解释、适用统一和自我拘束等制度价值。相应地,执纪执法指导性案例的法治逻辑主要体现为内容解释性、效力参照性和适用依附性。内容层面,其需要遵循不相抵触原则,同时在解释权限上不同于纪检监察解释;效力层面,"应当参照"对应着附条件性适用且无权审查;适用层面,其不得直接、独立地作为执纪执法依据。未来可通过进一步补强合法性依据、融入成文法体系和推进制度化规范化等,在法治轨道上有序推进执纪执法指导性案例工作。
The Rule of Law Logic and Institutional Optimization of Guiding Cases of Discipline and Law Enforcement
The guiding function of guiding cases of discipline and law enforcement mainly involve three dimensions,including limited interpretation of disciplinary inspection and supervision norms under explanatory guidance,promotion of horizontal and vertical unity and integration of discipline and law under unified guidance,and self-restraint of disciplinary inspection and supervision discretion under self-control guidance.Correspondingly,the rule of law logic of guiding cases of discipline and law enforcement is mainly reflected in their interpretive content,referential effectiveness,and dependent application.At the content level,they shall not conflict with relevant rules or exceed specific application rules,and at the same time,it is different from the interpretation of the disciplinary supervision in the interpretation authority;From the perspective of effectiveness,"shall refer to"corresponds to conditional application and no right to review;In terms of application,these cases cannot be directly or independently used as a basis for discipline and law enforcement.In the future,in order to promote the development of guiding cases system of discipline and law enforcement on the track of the rule of law,it is necessary to further strengthen its legitimacy basis,promote its integration into the written legal system,and accelerate its institutionalized and standardized construction.

guiding cases of discipline and law enforcementcase guidance systemguidance functionrule of law logicinstitutional optimization

石泽华、秦前红

展开 >

武汉大学法学院,湖北武汉 430072

执纪执法指导性案例 案例指导制度 指导功能 法治逻辑 制度优化

2024

河北法学
河北政法职业学院 河北省法学会

河北法学

CHSSCD北大核心
影响因子:0.992
ISSN:1002-3933
年,卷(期):2024.42(9)