首页|马克思过渡理论的两种阐释模式——以罗伯特·布伦纳为例

马克思过渡理论的两种阐释模式——以罗伯特·布伦纳为例

扫码查看
罗伯特·布伦纳区分了马克思封建主义向资本主义过渡理论的两种阐释模式:第一种模式是早期以分工和生产力为核心的"分工模式",这种模式来自于斯密,它潜在地蕴含了非历史的倾向;第二种模式是晚期以生产关系为核心的"生产方式模式",这种模式从特定的生产关系出发,肯定了不同生产关系下经济发展的特殊性.布伦纳认为,马克思两种过渡理论存在本质区别,只有第二种模式才具有开创性和解释力,但这种模式没有得到马克思的完善.布伦纳割裂了马克思过渡理论中政治和经济、生产力和生产关系、抽象和具体的关系,导致他没有准确把握马克思过渡理论的连续性和一致性.
Two Interpretation Modes of Marx's Transition Theory——A Case Study of Robert Brenner
Robert Brenner distinguished two modes of interpretation for Marx's theory of the transition from feudalism to capitalism:the first mode was the early"division of labor mode"centered on division of labor and productive forces,which originated from Smith and potentially contained non-historical tendencies;the second mode is the late stage"mode of production"centered on production relations,which starts from specific production relations and affirms the particularity of economic development under different production relations.Brenner believed that there was an essential difference between Marx's two transitional theories,and only the second model has pioneering and explanatory power,but this model has not been perfected by Marx.Brenner severed the relationship between politics and economy,productive forces and production relations,abstract and concrete in Marx's transitional theory,resulting in his failure to accurately grasp its continuity and consistency.

MarxRobert Brennertransition theoryproductivitysocial property relations

王俊洁、姜海波

展开 >

黑龙江大学哲学学院,黑龙江哈尔滨 150080

马克思 罗伯特·布伦纳 过渡理论 生产力 社会财产关系

2024

哈尔滨学院学报
哈尔滨学院

哈尔滨学院学报

影响因子:0.269
ISSN:1004-5856
年,卷(期):2024.45(11)