湖南警察学院学报2024,Vol.36Issue(4) :5-17.

论亲子鉴定申请司法审查要件的检视与完善——基于子女最佳利益原则的展开

On the Inspection and Improvement of the Elements of Judicial Review of the Application of Paternity Identification——Based on the Principle of the Best Interests of the Child

夏先华 曹颖
湖南警察学院学报2024,Vol.36Issue(4) :5-17.

论亲子鉴定申请司法审查要件的检视与完善——基于子女最佳利益原则的展开

On the Inspection and Improvement of the Elements of Judicial Review of the Application of Paternity Identification——Based on the Principle of the Best Interests of the Child

夏先华 1曹颖2
扫码查看

作者信息

  • 1. 湘潭大学,湖南 湘潭 411105
  • 2. 中南财经政法大学,湖北 武汉 430073
  • 折叠

摘要

亲子鉴定申请的司法审查与程序启动涉及子女的切身利益,其对于血缘真实主义的价值追求应受到限制,且以子女最佳利益作为首要考量因素.从亲子鉴定申请司法审查要件的适用现状来看,其存在一般性审查要件的适用刚性不足、对于子女利益保护的司法审查缺位、"欠缺合意型"申请的审查要件适用紊乱等问题.为贯彻子女最佳利益原则,有必要明确程序性要件、证明必要性要件在亲子鉴定中的适用内容,并规范法院的审查行为.同时,应将子女最佳利益作为独立的审查要件,明确其评判与确定要素,加强对8周岁以上子女的意见听审,并通过引入程序辅助人制度保障子女的意见表达.对于"欠缺合意型"的亲子鉴定申请,需论证"提供必要证据"作为审查要件的正当性,并将其证明标准合理设定为"存在合理怀疑".

Abstract

The judicial review and procedural initiation of paternity identification applications involve children's personal interests,and their pursuit of the value of blood relation realism should be limited,with the best interests of children as the primary consideration.From the current situation of the application of judicial review elements for paternity identification applications,there are such problems as insufficient rigidity in the application of general review requirements,lack of judicial review for the protection of children's interests,and disorderly application of review elements for"lack of agreement"applications.In order to implement the principle of the best interests of children,it is necessary to clarify the application of procedural and evidential elements in paternity identification,and regulate the court's review behavior.At the same time,the best interests of children should be regarded as an independent review element,and its evaluation and determination elements should be clarified.The hearing of opinions on children over 8 years should be strengthened,and the system of procedural assistants should be introduced to ensure the expression of children's opinions.For parent-child identification applications that lack consensus,it is necessary to demonstrate the legitimacy of"providing necessary evidence"as the examination element,and set the proof standard reasonably as"the existence of reasonable doubt".

关键词

亲子鉴定/司法审查要件/子女最佳利益/亲子关系

Key words

paternity identification/elements of judicial review/the best interests of the child/parent-child relationship

引用本文复制引用

出版年

2024
湖南警察学院学报
湖南警察学院

湖南警察学院学报

影响因子:0.282
ISSN:2095-1140
段落导航相关论文