首页|承认形式的缘起及其演进——霍耐特对黑格尔《耶拿实在哲学》的解读

承认形式的缘起及其演进——霍耐特对黑格尔《耶拿实在哲学》的解读

扫码查看
黑格尔早期的《耶拿实在哲学》日益受到学界的关注,霍耐特认为《耶拿实在哲学》比《伦理体系》更为清晰地将层次化的承认形式(即爱、法律和团结)作为精神发展的逻辑主线.首先,主观精神由于不满足于自身的状态,期望在现实中(即他者身上)寻找自我,去拥有自己的本质,最初表现为性别互动所产生的爱的承认形式.但家庭领域中的爱注定是未完成的经验领域,一旦主观精神走出家庭,精神经历了"自然状态"到社会契约的过渡,黑格尔就以法律承认形式作为中介,构建起新的个体意志(即法人)的经验阶段.但犯罪行为的挑衅,就会使作为普遍意志的法律陷入再次分裂的境地.因此,黑格尔力图在更高的国家和共同体领域中对法律体系进行重构,霍耐特指出这就是团结的承认形式.在霍耐特看来,《耶拿实在哲学》中的承认线索在后来的《精神现象学》《法哲学原理》中得到进一步丰富,从而论证了承认形式的演进,本质上反映出精神的外化和现实化历程.
The Origins of Forms of Recognition and Their Evolution:Honneth's Interpretation of Hegel's Jenenser Realphilosophie
Hegel's Jenenser Realphilosophie has received increasing international scholarly attention.Honneth argues that Jenenser Realphilosophie presents,more clearly than System der Sittlichkeit,hierarchical forms of recognition(i.e.,love,law,and solidarity)as the logical main line of spiritual development.First of all,the subjective spirit,being unsatisfied with its own state,expects to find itself in reality(i.e.,in the Other),to own its own essence,which initially manifests it-self in the form of recognition of love resulting from gender interaction.But love in the family sphere is destined to be an un-finished field of experience.Once the subjective spirit leaves the family,and the spirit undergoes the transition from the"state of nature"to the social contract,Hegel uses the legal form of recognition as an intermediary to build a new empirical stage of individual will(i.e.,legal person).However,the provocation of the criminal act will cause the law as a universal will to be divided again.Therefore,Hegel seeks to reconstruct the legal system in the higher sphere of the state and the community,which,as Honneth points out,is the form of recognition of"solidarity".In Honneth's view,the threads of recognition in Jenenser Realphi-losophie are further enriched in Phanomenologie des Geistes and Grundlinien DerPhilosophie des Rechts,which proves that the evo-lution of the forms of recognition essentially reflects the process of externalization and actualization of spirit.

Jenenser Realphilosophieforms of recognitionlovelawsolidarity

陈良斌

展开 >

东南大学马克思主义学院

东南大学(江苏南京211189)

《耶拿实在哲学》 承认形式 法律 团结

江苏省社科基金项目中央高校基本科研业务费项目江苏高校"青蓝工程"资助项目

20ZXB0042242023S30019

2024

湖南师范大学社会科学学报
湖南师范大学

湖南师范大学社会科学学报

CSTPCDCSSCICHSSCD北大核心
影响因子:1.06
ISSN:1000-2529
年,卷(期):2024.53(1)
  • 7