首页|工商业与人权视角下母公司直接责任实践的新发展及我国应对

工商业与人权视角下母公司直接责任实践的新发展及我国应对

扫码查看
随着工商业与人权运动的发展,为获得有效救济,因公司集团中子公司行为遭受人身损害的受害人倾向于在跨国企业母公司母国法院提起诉讼.然而根据现有法律,子公司的责任并不必然及于母公司.鉴于建立以刺破公司面纱为基础的间接责任的难度较高,且刺破公司面纱制度与公司集团背景下子公司境外侵权案件并不适配,司法实践中发展出以注意义务为代表的直接责任判断依据,后在联合国《指导原则》的推动下,人权尽责义务成为直接责任成立的新依据.近年来,强制性人权尽责立法渐成大势.人权尽责义务旨在事前预防,注意义务多为事后救济,将二者相结合的强制性人权尽责法对实现人权保护目的最具可行性.我国可考虑制定包含人权尽责义务与注意义务的强制性人权尽责法,发挥公司法与侵权法的合力作用;可根据现有侵权责任理论解释出注意义务的存在,使工商业与人权诉讼在法院获得受理;企业应做好合规工作,注重人权保护结果的落地与实现.
New Development of Parent Company Direct Liability Theory from the Perspective of Business and Human Rights and China’s Strategies
With the development of Business and Human Rights(BHR)movement,in order to access to effective remedy,victims who suffer personal injury due to the actions of subsidiaries within a corporate group tend to file lawsuits in the home country courts of multinational corporations in order to obtain effective remedies.However,according to existing laws,the liability born by a subsidiary is not surely extended to its parent company.Due to the difficulties of establishing indirect lia-bility based on piercing the corporate veil,and the rareness of its application in the tort cases,the judicial practice develops the theory of direct liability represented by the duty of care.Following the UN Guiding Principles on Business and Human Rights,the human rights due diligence(HRDD)becomes the new basis for the direct liability theory.In recent years,mandatory HRDD legislation has gradually become a trend.The HRDD aims at the prevention in advance,while the duty of care focuses on the remedy afterwards.The mandatory HRDD law combining the HRDD and the duty of care is the most feasible for achieving the purpose of human rights protection.When it comes to China,the legislator should legislate a man-datory HRDD law that includes the HRDD obligation and the duty of care,so as to bring into play the combined effect of corporate law and tort law.Besides,the judges can explain the existence of the duty of care from the existing tort liability theory,so that BHR litigation can have real triable issue and be accepted by the Chinese people’s courts.Finally,Chinese enterprises should do a good job of compliance and focus on the implementation and realization of human rights protection.

duty of carehuman rights due diligencedirect liabilityparent company liabilitybusiness and human rights

王岩

展开 >

华侨大学法学院 福建 泉州 362021

注意义务 人权尽责义务 直接责任 母公司责任 工商业与人权

2024

华侨大学学报(哲学社会科学版)
华侨大学

华侨大学学报(哲学社会科学版)

CHSSCD
影响因子:1.024
ISSN:1006-1398
年,卷(期):2024.(6)