首页|论茅坤对柳宗元"与故人书"的重估及其影响

论茅坤对柳宗元"与故人书"的重估及其影响

扫码查看
在茅坤之前,柳宗元的"与故人书"往往被认为乞哀望援,格调不高,其评价以否定居多.茅坤仕途坎坷,中岁削籍,一腔郁愤,与柳宗元为近,乞哀望援,亦所不免,因而能够揣情度理,拨弃旧见,第一次全面肯定"与故人书"的文学价值.茅坤认为,柳宗元"与故人书"的"沉郁"风格,源自司马迁《报任安书》和杨恽《报孙会宗书》,实系"发愤著书"的产物.他还认为,柳宗元"与故人书"代表了其在古文运动中的最高成就,与此前带有六朝锦色的骈散相兼之作判然有别.这就从中国优秀文学传统的继承和中国散文骈散分流的宏大视角肯定了柳宗元"与故人书"在中国散文史上的重要价值,可以看作柳宗元散文批评的分水岭.清人基本接受了茅坤的新评价,并在此基础上更加深刻、详尽地阐明了柳宗元"与故人书"的审美价值.茅坤对柳宗元"与故人书"的重估是柳文经典化过程中的关捩,对清代柳文地位的提升具有先导意义.
Mao Kun's Reevaluation of Liu Zongyuan's Letters with His Old Friends and Its Influence
Before Mao Kun,Liu Zongyuan's letters with his old friends were often regarded as begging for help and a somber style;critics'comments on them are mainly negative.Mao Kun,with a bumpy career similar to that of Liu Zongyuan,also begged for help from his old friends.Therefore,he sympathized with Liu Zongyuan and fully affirmed the literary value of Liu's letters with his old friends for the first time.Mao Kun believed that the"somber"style of Liu Zongyuan's letters with his old friends came from Sima Qian and Yang Yun,which was the product of"writing from anger".He also believed that Liu Zongyuan's letters with his old friends represent his highest achievement in the classical literary movement in the Tang Dynasty,which were quite different from the previous parallel prose of the Six Dynasties.All this confirms the important value of Liu Zongyuan's letters with his old friends in the history of Chinese prose from the perspective of the inheritance of China's excellent literary tradition and the diversion of parallel prose and the prose.It can be seen as the watershed of Liu Zongyuan's prose criticism.Mao Kun's reevaluation was basically accepted by the scholars in the Qing Dynasty,who,on this basis,more profoundly and more subtly expounded the aesthetic value of Liu Zongyuan's letters with his old friends.Mao Kun's reevaluation of Liu Zongyuan's letters with his old friends plays a vital role in the canonization of Liu Zongyuan's prose,and has a leading significance for promoting the literary status of Liu Zongyuan's prose in the Qing Dynasty.

Mao KunLiu Zongyuanletters with his old friendsreevaluation

黄文浩、付琼

展开 >

浙江财经大学人文与传播学院,浙江杭州 310018

茅坤 柳宗元 "与故人书" 重估

国家社会科学基金后期资助项目(2022)

22FZWB058

2024

湖州师范学院学报
湖州师范学院

湖州师范学院学报

影响因子:0.301
ISSN:1009-1734
年,卷(期):2024.46(5)
  • 44