For subjective and objective reasons,scholars who study Qin Guan's Ci have rarely mentioned the version by Huang Zan and the version by Meng Chunhui,so there is no discussion on the version of Qin Guan's Ci before Jiajing period of the Ming Dynasty.However,after comparison and research,the author has found that these two versions are not only the only copies both at home and abroad,but also extremely important ones for investigating the changes of the versions of Qin Guan's Ci before Jiajing period of the Ming Dynasty.They are worthy of further studying.