首页|大学生理解、认同与采纳同伴评语的实证研究

大学生理解、认同与采纳同伴评语的实证研究

扫码查看
探讨在线教学中学生对同伴评语的采纳行为,关注学生对不同类型评语的理解、认同程度,以及这些因素对采纳行为的影响.选取师范类S高校"现代教育技术"课程某章节的作业任务作为研究对象,通过在线同伴互评活动观察学生的评语行为,研究学生对不同类型评语的理解、认同和采纳程度,并通过相关性分析探讨这些因素之间的关系.研究表明,认知类评语更易被学生理解、认同和采纳;"模糊限制语""解释说明"和"具体解决"三类评语与学生的采纳行为显著正相关,其中"模糊限制语"与采纳行为的关联最为显著;一轮互评后,全班学生平均成绩显著提高.为促进互评质量和反思性学习,教师应制定详细的互评标准,协助学生理解评语,引导学生提供包含详细修改意见的认知类评语,并在必要时解释评语,以加强学生的认知理解.
An Empirical Study on Undergraduates'Understanding,Recognition and Adoption of Peer Comments
This study aims to examine the behaviors of students in online teaching environments concerning their adoption of peer feedback.It specifically delves into students'comprehension and acceptance of various types of feedback and investigates how these factors influence their adoption actions.The research focuses on a homework assignment from the"Modern Educational Tech-nology"course at S Normal University.Through online peer evaluation activities,students'responses to diverse feedback types were observed.This study assesses their levels of understanding,acceptance,and adoption of the feedback and analyzes the relationships among these factors using correlation analysis.Feedback of a cognitive nature is found to be more readily understood,accepted,and adopted by students.Feedback categories such as"vague restrictive language""explanatory comments"and"specific solutions"demonstrate a significant positive correlation with students'adoption behaviors.Notably,"vague restrictive language"exhibits the strongest correlation with these behaviors.Furthermore,a significant improvement in the average grades of the entire class is ob-served following one round of peer assessment.Conclusion:To foster the quality of peer assessment and reflective learning,educa-tors should develop precise criteria for peer review.They should facilitate students'comprehension of feedback,encourage the pro-vision of cognitive feedback that includes detailed suggestions for revisions,and provide explanations of feedback where necessary to enhance students'understanding.

Peer feedbackOnline peer evaluationPeer reviewAdopt behavior

昂娟、陈媛

展开 >

南京特殊教育师范学院数学与信息科学学院,江苏南京 210038

同伴互评 在线同伴互评 同伴评语 采纳行为

2024

荆楚理工学院学报
荆楚理工学院

荆楚理工学院学报

影响因子:0.168
ISSN:1008-4657
年,卷(期):2024.39(3)