首页|职业本科院校能避免学术漂移吗——基于英德的比较分析

职业本科院校能避免学术漂移吗——基于英德的比较分析

扫码查看
防范学术漂移是推进职业本科院校建设亟需回应的时代命题.组织场域理论为分析职业本科院校学术漂移提供了极具解释力的理论框架.英国"92后大学"和德国双元制大学均由职业教育办学特点鲜明的非大学高等教育机构升格而来,前者发生学术漂移,后者坚守职业导向.这既表明职业本科院校的学术漂移并非必然,也表明原机构的"职教基因"不是避免职业本科院校学术漂移的绝对保证.遵循产业逻辑,通过制度创业构建区别于传统高等教育的高等职业教育组织场域才是防范职业本科院校学术漂移的关键.其中规制性要素重在政策定位与经费机制,规范性要素重在产业认同与标杆示范,文化认知性要素重在文化传统与社会评价.基于此,我国防范职业本科院校学术漂移应注重强化政策支持与经费供给,增强行业企业的主体地位,遴选优质院校作为组织模仿标杆,营造崇尚技能的社会氛围.
Can Vocational University Avoid Academic Drift?Based on the Comparison of Britain and Germany
Preventing academic drift is an imperative for promoting the development of vocational university in China nowadays.Organizational field theory provides a highly explanatory theoretical framework for analyzing academic drift of vocational university.Although both British post-92 universities and German dual universities were upgraded from non-university higher education institutions with distinctive characteristics of vocational education,the former experienced academic drift while the latter remain vocational.This shows that the academic drift of vocational university is not inevitable,and also shows that the"vocational education gene"of the original institution is not an guarantee to avoid the academic drift of vocational university.The key to preventing the academic drift of vocational university relies on constructing a new higher vocational education organizational field by institutional entrepreneurship,which is based on the industrial logic and separated from the traditional higher education field.The institutional elements underlying such a field highly depends on the regulatory element of policy orientation and funding mechanism,the normative element of industrial recognition and benchmarking,and the cultural-perceptual element of cultural traditions and social evaluations.Therefore,in order to prevent the academic drift of vocational universities,China should focus on strengthening policy support and funding,deepen industry-education integration to strengthen industry's status,select high-quality colleges as benchmarks,and shape cultural-cognitive concepts to create the social atmosphere in which skills are highly valued.

vocational universityacademic driftorganizational fieldinstitutional logicgovernance

许宇飞、关晶

展开 >

上海师范大学教育学院(上海 200234)

职业本科院校 学术漂移 组织场域 制度逻辑 治理

2023年全国教育科学规划国家一般课题

BJA230038

2024

教育发展研究
上海市教育科学研究院 上海市高等教育学会

教育发展研究

CSTPCDCSSCICHSSCD北大核心
影响因子:1.416
ISSN:1008-3855
年,卷(期):2024.44(13)