首页|宁做"鸡头"不做"凤尾"?——新高考背景下优质高中对学生学业表现的影响

宁做"鸡头"不做"凤尾"?——新高考背景下优质高中对学生学业表现的影响

扫码查看
基于某新高考省份高中毕业生的大规模问卷调查数据,使用断点回归方法研究进入不同梯队优质高中对学生高考成绩、选科选考及学习投入的影响.研究发现:从学业成绩来看,优质高中并没有显著提升学生的高考成绩;相比在第二梯队优质高中做"鸡头",勉强进入第一梯队优质高中的"凤尾"学生甚至可能面临成绩损失.从学习行为来看,"鸡头"和"凤尾"学生在选科选考和学习投入方面差异不大;相比非优质高中的"鸡头",第二梯队优质高中的"凤尾"学生更晚确定选考科目、校内学习投入更少;相比第二梯队优质高中的"鸡头",第一梯队优质高中的"凤尾"学生的校内学习投入更多、但学习效率更低.本文的研究发现侧面验证了政府部门监管择校、实施教育资源均衡政策的必要性.
Is It Better to be "a Big Fish in a Little Pond" than "a Little Fish in a Big Pond"?A Study on the Influence of Elite High Schools on Students'Academic Performance under New Scheme of College Entrance Examination
Using large scale questionnaire survey data from high school graduates in a province that implements the new scheme of college entrance examination,this study examines the impact of elite high schools(including both Tier-1 and Tier-2 high schools)on students'academic performance,subject selection,and learning engagement in a fuzzy regression discontinuity design.We find that,overall,participating in elite high schools does not increase the academic performance for students around the cutoff.Students who barely enter Tier-1 high schools perform even worse than their counterparts in Tier-2 high schools.In terms of learning behavior,the differences in subject selection and learning engagement among students around the cutoff are small.Students in Tier-2 high schools tend to decide on their subjects later and spend less time studying on campus compared with their counterparts in non-elite high schools.Students in Tier-1 high schools spend more time studying on campus with lower learning efficiency than their counterparts in Tier-2 high schools.Our findings indirectly verify the necessity of the government supervision of school selection and the implementation of the policy of balancing educational resources.

academic performancenew scheme of college entrance examinationregression discontinuityschool selectioneducation resources equilibrium

马莉萍、冯沁雪、周雪涵

展开 >

北京大学 教育经济研究所,北京 100871

南京大学 教育研究院,南京 210023

学业表现 新高考 断点回归 择校 教育资源均衡

教育部人文社会科学重点研究基地重大项目

22JJD880002

2024

教育与经济
华中师范大学,中国教育经济学研究会

教育与经济

CSTPCDCSSCICHSSCD北大核心
影响因子:1.183
ISSN:1003-4870
年,卷(期):2024.40(3)