首页|本土转译视角下的福建近代"中西合璧式"教堂建筑

本土转译视角下的福建近代"中西合璧式"教堂建筑

扫码查看
福建近代"中西合璧式"教堂建筑是中西建筑文化交流与碰撞的产物,既有研究多将"中西合璧式"等同于近代教会本土化策略下的"中国式样",而忽视了以中国传统建筑为基础的本土化演进.文章从"建筑可译论"视角,以19座典型的"中西合璧式"教堂建筑为例,探讨了近代"中西合璧式"的形式转译.首先,文章溯源并辨析了福建近代教堂建筑转译,及以中国传统建筑为基础的"中译西"与以西式教堂为基础的"西译中"两种途径;其次,总结了福建近代教堂建筑转译的四种主要类型及其可替换原则;最后,分析了福建近代教堂建筑的转译矛盾及其原因,并以下邳天主堂为例进行了具体的剖析,发现了产生这种矛盾的根本原因是近代中西建筑"词汇"背后的"文法"差异.
A Study of the Early Modern'Sino-Western Hybrid Style'Churches in Fujian Province from the Perspective of'Local Architectural Translation'
The early modern'Sino-Western hybrid style'churches in Fujian Province are the prod-ucts of the exchange and collision of Chinese and Western architectural cultures.Most of the ex-isting research equates the'Sino-Western hybrid style'with the Chinese style under the localisa-tion strategy of western Christian Church,while neglecting the localisation evolution based on traditional Chinese architecture.Adopting the theory of'architectural translatability',this article examines 19'Sino-Western hybrid style'churches to discuss the formal translation of this style in the early modern era(1840-1949).First,it traces the source and analyses the translation of early modern churches in Fujian Province,discovering two approaches including'Chinese-to-Western translation'based on traditional Chinese architec-ture and'Western-to-Chinese translation'based on Western-style churches.Second,it identifies four types of architectural translation and the transferrable principles.Finally,it interrogates the translation contradictions and the reasons behind.A detailed analysis of the Xiapi Catholic Church in Fu'an finds that the underlying cause of this contradiction is the difference in'grammar'behind the'vocabularies'of Chinese and Western architecture at the time.

early modern churches in Fujian Prov-ince'Sino-Western hybrid style'local architec-tural translationarchitectural translation types'vocabularies''grammar'

朱友利、杜书波

展开 >

三峡大学(宜昌443002)土木与建筑学院

三峡大学(宜昌443002)湖北省地质灾害防治工程技术研究中心

聊城大学建筑工程学院(聊城252000)

同济大学建筑与城市规划学院(上海200092)

展开 >

福建近代教堂建筑 "中西合璧式" 本土转译 建筑转译类型 "词汇" "文法"

2024

建筑遗产
中国科技出版传媒股份有限公司,同济大学

建筑遗产

ISSN:1004-9217
年,卷(期):2024.(2)