摘要
包括2018年诺奖得主本庶佑在内的不少国内外研究者持有重大创新论文往往发表于非顶级期刊的观点未见数据证实,但对我国科技期刊发展、学术评价以及个别研究者认知可能产生负面影响.在数学、物理、化学、生物、医学、地球科学、经济学7个学科的诺奖级奖项官网及谷歌学术中检索1979-2019年上述7个学科获奖论文,统计7个学科诺奖级获奖论文发表期刊的分布情况.结果表明,7个学科的大多数重大创新论文均在所属学科影响因子排名前10位的期刊发表.重大创新论文往往发表于非顶级期刊的观点只是对少数情况的总结,并不符合多数情况.
Abstract
Many researchers,including 2018 Nobel Prize winner Tasuku Honjo,argue that Nobel Prize level papers are often not published in top journals.This opinion has not been confirmed by data,but it is quite popular.It may have negative impact on the development of Chinese academic journals and scientific research activities.This paper analyzes the journal distribution of Nobel Prize level papers in seven disciplines(Mathematics,Physics,Chemistry,Biology,Medi-cine,Geoscience and Economics)for discussing whether or not breakthrough papers are often to publish in top journals.Breakthrough papers from seven disciplines from 1979 to 2019 were retrieved,journal impact factors,journal ranking in JCR in paper publication year had been collected and analysed.Statistical results show that majority breakthrough papers in seven disciplines had been published in top journals.So the opinion that breakthrough papers had often been not pub-lished in top journals which many researchers including 2018 Nobel laureate Tasuku Honjo agreed is not right on the whole.
NETL
NSTL
万方数据