科学与社会2024,Vol.14Issue(3) :26-40.DOI:10.19524/j.cnki.10-1009/g3.2024.03.026

归责与规范:基于主动式脑机接口的道德责任层级研究

Attribution and Norms:A study on the hierarchical moral responsibility based on active brain-computer interfaces

杨雨 王国豫
科学与社会2024,Vol.14Issue(3) :26-40.DOI:10.19524/j.cnki.10-1009/g3.2024.03.026

归责与规范:基于主动式脑机接口的道德责任层级研究

Attribution and Norms:A study on the hierarchical moral responsibility based on active brain-computer interfaces

杨雨 1王国豫2
扫码查看

作者信息

  • 1. 复旦大学哲学学院;复旦大学科技伦理与人类未来研究院
  • 2. 复旦大学科技伦理与人类未来研究院
  • 折叠

摘要

主动式脑机接口介导的"人工行动"挑战了我们对行动本质的传统认识,也带来了道德责任的归责困境.通过对脑机接口介导行动中的道德责任进行层级划分,能够有效地对行动主体的道德责任进行差异化分配.这种差异化分配基于两个核心层面:一是评估主体的介导行动是否与其意图相符,以及他们是否能够预见行动的可能结果;二是考虑主动式脑机接口的不同应用方向和人机"共享控制"的技术特性,确保在不同应用情境下能够合理界定道德责任范围及其责任限度.对道德责任的层级划分,能够更为恰当地满足社会对主动式脑机接口终端用户的道德期望,为脑机接口介导行动的道德责任研究提供一个具有参考价值的分析框架.

Abstract

Active brain-computer interfaces(BCIs)and the"artificial actions"they mediate challenge our traditional understanding of the nature of action and present dilemmas in attributing moral responsibility.By applying a hierarchical understanding of moral responsibility in actions mediated by BCIs,we can effectively differentiate the moral responsibilities of agents to address the unique limitations they face in control and perception.This differentiated assessment is based on two core aspects:first,evaluating whether the mediated actions align with the agent's intentions and whether they can foresee the possible outcomes of their actions;second,considering the various applications of active BCIs and the technical characteristics of"shared control"between human and machine,ensuring that the scope and limits of moral responsibility are reasonably defined in different contexts.The hierarchical division of moral responsibility can more appropriately meet the moral expectations for end-users of active BCIs,providing a valuable analytical framework for the research of moral responsibility in BCI-mediated actions.

关键词

主动式脑机接口/道德责任/归责/责任层级

Key words

active BCI/moral responsibility/attribution/hierarchy of responsibility

引用本文复制引用

出版年

2024
科学与社会
中科院科技政策与管理科学研究所 中国科学院学部

科学与社会

CHSSCD
影响因子:0.922
ISSN:2095-1949
段落导航相关论文