首页|从检察主导到法院主导:涉案企业合规改革的理想模式

从检察主导到法院主导:涉案企业合规改革的理想模式

扫码查看
企业合规改革在司法层面的刑事激励手段,包括前期检察机关的合规不起诉和后期法院主动参与的合规量刑从宽两方面.现阶段的理论研究和实践探索多着眼于前者,而对后者的关注偏少.当前实践中,运用合规不起诉存在适用范围有限、检察求刑权越界、正当性不足等问题,限制了合规改革的效果.扩大改革辐射范围,推进建立审判环节刑事激励体系,是以审判为中心的诉讼制度改革的题中之义.理想的合规改革模式是从主体、制度、证据、审限四个维度进行解释论分析,明确法院的主导、裁判地位,确立合规从宽的量刑激励制度,赋予合规材料法定证据资格,优化审限管理,建立法院参与改革的"四梁八柱",解决无法可依、无章可循等应用障碍,以更好应对现实挑战.
From prosecutorial leadership to court leadership:the ideal model for corporate compliance reform
The criminal incentives for corporate compliance reform at the judicial level include the procuratorate's compliance with non-prosecution in the early stage and the court's active participation in compliance with sen-tencing leniency in the later stage.At this stage,the theoretical research and the practical exploration focus more on the former,while paying less attention to the latter.In current practice,the use of compliance with non-prose-cution has problems such as limited scope of application,overstepping of prosecutorial powers to seek punishment and insufficient legitimacy,which limit the effectiveness of compliance reform.Expanding the scope of reform and promoting the establishment of a criminal incentive system in the trial process is the essence of the trial-cen-tered litigation system reform.The ideal compliance reform model is to conduct an interpretative analysis from the four dimensions of subject,system,evidence and time limit of trials,clarify the leading and refereeing status of the court,establish a lenient sentencing incentive system for compliance,grant legal evidence qualifications to compli-ance materials,optimize the management of time limit of trials,establish the"four beams and eight pillars"for courts to participate in reform,and solve application obstacles such as no legal basis and no rules to follow,so as to better respond to practical challenges.

compliance of enterprise involved in the casecourt's participationcompliance sentencing incen-tivesevidencetime limit of trials

梁旭、赵子微

展开 >

河北省高级人民法院,河北 石家庄 050051

河北省衡水市中级人民法院,河北 衡水 053000

涉案企业合规 法院参与 合规量刑激励 证据 审理期限

2024

辽宁公安司法管理干部学院学报
辽宁公安司法管理干部学院

辽宁公安司法管理干部学院学报

CHSSCD
影响因子:0.141
ISSN:1009-1416
年,卷(期):2024.(2)
  • 37