首页|文章文法视野下义例、史法、义法之辨析

文章文法视野下义例、史法、义法之辨析

扫码查看
学者们往往将方苞所谓文章义法等同于经学义例、书法或史法,此观点值得商榷.义例、史法对文章文法的发展都有不同程度的影响,它们都重视大义的书写,也影响到义法说对文章大义指向的重视以及将义与法密切关联的主张.不过,经学大义或史学大义在某种程度上是学者共同认可或遵守的价值观念,而文章大义则往往体现作家个人的学养、精神等等.义例、史法、文章义法也都关注文章写作之"法",都会考虑书与不书或材料的取舍等问题,但在"法"的内涵和指向上又有明显区别.经学家对书法的分析主要体现在文章字句上,即所谓"一字褒贬",史法的根本在于对体例的把握;《史通》开启了叙事文法的总结,明人以此为基础,通过《左传》《史记》等的评点使叙事的篇章之法得到充分认识和发展;方苞义法说的提出又以明人为基础,简化明代以来层出不穷的炫目、奇妙之法,主张法的运用随义而变化,更关注最基本的篇章法则,确立了清代文章学的基本走向.
Discrimination of the Concepts of Yili,Shifa and Yifa from the Perspective of Essay Writing Methods
The concepts of Yili(essay structuring methods)and Shifa(history writing methods)affected the development of essay writing methods in varying degrees.Highlighting thoughts of essays,these two con-cepts also affected the viewpoints of the theory of Yifa(essay writing principles)that emphasizes the thoughts of essays and the connection of thoughts with corresponding methods.The thoughts of Confucian classics studies or historiography are somewhat the common values recognized by scholars of all ages,while the thoughts of an essay often reflect the author's learning and spiritual temperament.The concepts of Yili,Shifa and Yifa all emphasize the"methods"of essay writing and material selection,but they differ significantly in connotation and denotation.Specifically,Confucian classics scholars emphasized the usage of words and sentences,believing that"one can praise or criticize a person even with a single word",while the foundation of Shifa lies in the stylistic rules and layout.In his seminal work Shi Tong(Generality of Historiography),the Tang scholar Liu Zhiji summarized the narrative history writing method,which was further accepted by the Ming scholars in their commentaries on Zuo Zhuan(The Chronicle of Zuo)and Shi Ji(Records of the Grand Historian).On this basis,the Qing scholar Fang Bao put forward his theory of Yifa to reduce the flashy writ-ing methods used since the Ming,advocating that writing methods should change with thoughts and priority should be given to essay organization,which set the tendency of the Qing essay writing studies.

essay writing methodstheory of YifaYiliShifaFang Baothe Qing dynasty

宁俊红、王阳

展开 >

兰州大学 文学院,甘肃 兰州 730000

文章文法 义法说 义例 史法 方苞 清代

国家社会科学基金一般项目

20BZW035

2024

兰州大学学报(社会科学版)
兰州大学

兰州大学学报(社会科学版)

CSTPCDCSSCICHSSCD北大核心
影响因子:1.029
ISSN:1000-2804
年,卷(期):2024.52(1)
  • 36