首页|孟德斯鸠民族一般精神论的结构与意图

孟德斯鸠民族一般精神论的结构与意图

扫码查看
孟德斯鸠《论法的精神》旨在以与政治普遍主义相对的政治特殊主义,教导立法者保持节制精神,以图把人类世界引向自由与繁荣.立法者之所以需要保持节制精神,是因为复杂多样的人类社会限定了他们的行动空间.因此,立法者既需通过比较历史分析,寻找能够恰当保全人之自然的节制政体,还应理解并以恰当的方式重塑作为社会自然的民族一般精神,使之符合节制政体的政体原则,这是因为与政体原则的同一性决定了民族一般精神对制度变革的成败至关重要.孟德斯鸠虽然认为气候、土壤等物理因素对欧洲自由精神与亚洲奴役精神影响甚大,但并未堕入地理决定论,因为他坚信人力可控的道德因素对民族一般精神的影响更大.因此,立法者可以通过对道德因素的改变强化或消除物理因素的影响,而最合适的道德因素是商业.商业是以非强制的手段改变风俗风尚的最好路径,因为它恰当地顺应了人性的自然激情.
The Structure and Intention of Montesquieu's Theory of the General Spirit of a Nation
Montesquieu's The Spirit of the Laws seeks to teach legislators to maintain the spirit of modera-tion through political particularism opposite to political universalism,and guide the human world towards freedom and prosperity.The reason why legislators need to maintain such a spirit lies in his proposition that the complex and diverse human society limits their action space.Therefore,legislators should seek a moder-ate government system that can adequately preserve human nature through comparative historical analysis.Additionally,they should also understand and appropriately reshape the general spirit of a nation that repre-sents the nature of society.Aligning with the principles of the moderate government system,the general spirit of a nation plays a crucial role in the successful institutional reforms.Montesquieu argued that physical fac-tors such as climate and soil significantly shaped the spirit of liberty in Europe and slavery in Asia.However,he did not succumb to geographic determinism,as he firmly believed that moral elements,which are within human control,have a greater impact on the general spirit of a nation.Therefore,legislators can reinforce or eliminate the impact of physical factors by modifying moral elements.In this sense,commerce is the most effective moral element and method to change customs and manners through non-coercive means,as it conforms with the natural passions of human nature.

Montesquieulegislatorthe spirit of moderationthe general spirit of a nationcommerce

罗轶轩

展开 >

兰州大学 政治与国际关系学院,甘肃 兰州 730000

孟德斯鸠 立法者 节制精神 民族一般精神 商业

2024

兰州大学学报(社会科学版)
兰州大学

兰州大学学报(社会科学版)

CSTPCDCSSCICHSSCD北大核心
影响因子:1.029
ISSN:1000-2804
年,卷(期):2024.52(5)