首页|论专业法官会议制度设置的逻辑基础

论专业法官会议制度设置的逻辑基础

扫码查看
作为法院内部的一项设置,专业法官会议制度具有其历史逻辑、正当性逻辑、功能逻辑以及运作逻辑.从历史逻辑看,专业法官会议制度是在特定司法需求的持续驱动下,由庭务会、审判长联席会议等非正式机制演变而来.从正当性逻辑看,专业法官会议制度的正当性既源于其所形成的实践效用,亦源于我国法院整体本位运行模式、民主集中制组织原则以及集体主义文化传统.从功能逻辑看,专业法官会议制度之所以能发挥一系列功能,在于其推动了行权公开化与平权性制约、司法经验与智慧的共享以及司法共识的形成.从运作逻辑看,技术逻辑、成本逻辑以及控制逻辑共同构成了专业法官会议运行的内在机理.对专业法官会议制度的基础逻辑进行研究,有助于加深对该制度的理解,进一步奠定专业法官会议制度的理论基础.
On the Logical Basis of Establishing the Judges Conference System
The judges conference system as an internal mechanism of the court has its own logics of history,legitimacy,function and operation.Historically,the system,driven by continuous specific judicial demands,has evolved from informal mechanisms such as court affairs meetings and joint conferences of presiding judges.Its legitimacy stems from its practical utility and China's overall court-based operational model,the organizational principle of democratic centralism,and the collective cultural traditions.Functionally,it per-forms a series of roles in that it promotes the transparency of power exercise and constraints for equal rights,the sharing of judicial experience and wisdom,and the formation of judicial consensus.The operational logic lies in that the logics of technology,cost,and control jointly constitute its internal operational mechanism.Studying its logical basis is,therefore,conducive to deepening the understanding of this system,and further laying a theoretical foundation for it.

judges conferenceoverall court-based modelconstraints for equal rightstrial resource alloca-tionsystematic logic

顾培东、陈雨

展开 >

四川大学 法学院,四川 成都 610207

专业法官会议 法院整体本位 平权性制约 审判资源配置 制度逻辑

2024

兰州大学学报(社会科学版)
兰州大学

兰州大学学报(社会科学版)

CSTPCDCSSCICHSSCD北大核心
影响因子:1.029
ISSN:1000-2804
年,卷(期):2024.52(5)