首页|破产止息规则之反思与重构

破产止息规则之反思与重构

扫码查看
利息是资金使用的对价,债务人对资金的使用不因陷入破产而停止,破产受理后利息仍然产生。破产程序不改变实体权利的核心内容,因而破产受理后利息仍然存在,只是不能作为普通破产债权获得清偿。担保责任从属于实体债权,而实体债权不因破产债权的申报与确定而被削减。同时,由担保人承担破产申请受理后的利息,与当事人的合理预期一致,是对担保制度利益和社会经济利益的维护。因此,《民法典担保解释》第22条关于担保人不承担破产受理后利息之规定缺乏法理基础,且有突破《民法典》规定、超越司法解释权限之嫌,应予以纠正。《企业破产法》应摒弃破产止息规则而设立劣后债权制度,将破产受理后的利息纳入劣后债权之中,并规定利息的计算方式、实质合并破产时利息的计算时间等规则。
Rethinking and Reconstructing the Bankruptcy Stop Rule
Interest is a consideration for the use of funds;the debtor's use of funds does not cease when it falls into insolvency and interest continues to accrue after insolvency is admitted.Insolvency proceedings cannot change the core content of substantive rights,and thus interest continues to exist after the bankruptcy is admitted,but it cannot be discharged as an ordinary bankruptcy claim.Guarantee liability is subordinate to the entity claim,which is not reduced by the declaration and determination of the bankruptcy claim,and the guarantor bears the interest after the acceptance of the bankruptcy application,which is in line with the reasonable expectation of the parties,and protects the interests of the guarantee system and the social and economic interests.Therefore,Article 22 of the Civil Code Security Interpretation,which stipulates that the guarantor shall not bear the interest after acceptance of the bankruptcy application,lacks legal basis and is suspected of breaking through the provisions of the Civil Code and exceeding the authority of judicial interpretation,shall be corrected in the future.The Enterprise Insolvency Law should abandon the rule of bankruptcy moratorium and set up a system of subordinate claims,incorporating interest after bankruptcy acceptance into the subordinate claims and stipulating the rules on the calculation of interest and the time of calculation of interest in the case of substantively consolidated bankruptcy.

bankruptcy staysecured liabilitysubordinated claimssecurity subordinationsecured claims

张善斌、翟宇翔

展开 >

武汉大学法学院

德国奥格斯堡大学

破产止息 担保责任 劣后债权 担保从属性 担保债权

国家社科基金项目国家留学基金委员会2023年国家建设高水平大学公派研究生项目

22BFX078202306270202

2024

兰州学刊
兰州市社会科学院 兰州市社会科学界联合会

兰州学刊

CHSSCD
影响因子:0.401
ISSN:1005-3492
年,卷(期):2024.(6)