南昌航空大学学报(社会科学版)2024,Vol.26Issue(4) :25-31,79.DOI:10.3969/j.issn.2096-8574.2024.04.004

罗伯特?布伦纳对马克思资本主义起源理论的新阐释——"两种模式论"及其限度

Robert Brenner's New Interpretation of Marx's Theory of the Origins of Capitalism——The"Two-mode Theory"and Its Limitations

陈爱萍 冯思迈
南昌航空大学学报(社会科学版)2024,Vol.26Issue(4) :25-31,79.DOI:10.3969/j.issn.2096-8574.2024.04.004

罗伯特?布伦纳对马克思资本主义起源理论的新阐释——"两种模式论"及其限度

Robert Brenner's New Interpretation of Marx's Theory of the Origins of Capitalism——The"Two-mode Theory"and Its Limitations

陈爱萍 1冯思迈1
扫码查看

作者信息

  • 1. 江南大学 马克思主义学院,江苏 无锡 214122
  • 折叠

摘要

以社会财产关系为分析框架,罗伯特•布伦纳把马克思关于资本主义起源的理论阐释为"分工模式"和"生产模式"两个独立的发展阶段.他在批判"分工模式"并未超越商业化解释路径的基础上,将"生产模式"视为马克思在政治经济学批判中实现的与传统解释模式的决裂,从而也是全新阐发其历史唯物主义的标志.布伦纳对马克思资本主义起源理论的新阐释尤其是对传统解释模式的批判,对于理解历史发展的特殊性、重新认识资本主义起源具有一定的积极作用.然而,由于过于强调历史具体性和主体能动性,"两种模式论"不可避免地遮蔽了历史发展规律的一般性,并割裂了马克思思想发展的连续性.

Abstract

Using social property relations as an analytical framework,Robert Brenner interpreted Marx's theory of the origin of capitalism as two independent stages of development:the"division of labor mode"and the"production mode".On the basis of criticizing that the"division of labor mode"did not go beyond the commercialized interpretation path,he regarded the"production mode"as Marx's breakthrough from the traditional interpretation mode in political economy criticism,which is also a symbol of his new exposition of historical materialism.Brenner's new interpretation of Marx's theory of the origin of capitalism,especially his criticism of traditional modes of interpretation,has a certain positive effect on understanding the particularity of historical development and re-understanding the origin of capitalism.However,due to the excessive emphasis on historical specificity and subjectivity,the"two-mode theory"inevitably obscures the generality of the laws of historical development and disconnects Marx's thought development from continuity.

关键词

资本主义起源/社会财产关系/分工模式/生产模式

Key words

the origin of capitalism/social property relations/division of labor mode/production mode

引用本文复制引用

出版年

2024
南昌航空大学学报(社会科学版)
南昌航空大学

南昌航空大学学报(社会科学版)

CHSSCD
影响因子:0.304
ISSN:1009-1912
段落导航相关论文