首页|外资准入政策放松与制造业企业创新:以"负面清单"制度为例

外资准入政策放松与制造业企业创新:以"负面清单"制度为例

扫码查看
以2018年"负面清单"制度在全国的实施为标志性事件,基于2011-2020年我国制造业上市公司数据进行准自然实验,综合运用多种识别策略检验外资准入政策放松对我国制造业企业创新的影响效应与传导机制.双重差分模型分析表明"负面清单"制度的实施对我国制造业企业的创新能力提升具有显著促进作用,在稳健性、政策干扰排除检验后结论依然成立."负面清单"制度主要通过FDI的溢出效应、竞争效应和关联效应三个渠道促进制造业企业创新能力的提升.依据流入制造业FDI的"质优"转向新特点进行的异质性分析证实,外资准入政策放松后,并未导致低水平FDI的泛滥,而是促进了"质优"型FDI的流入,对弥合我国区域差距、倒逼企业创新、推动高技术和战略性产业的发展产生了显著的促进作用.最后针对企业和社会环境等因素进行调节效应的拓展分析发现,企业吸收能力越强、融资约束水平越低及地区营商环境水平越高,越能促进"负面清单"制度政策效应的发挥.文章把企业因素、产业因素和社会环境因素纳入到一个分析框架之中,从微观、中观和宏观层面进行深入分析,较为全面揭示了外资对本国企业创新能力变化的影响,为我国进一步扩大开放提供了理论和经验证据.
Relaxation of Foreign Investment Access Policies and Innovation of Manufacturing Enterprises:Taking the"Negative List"System as an Example
Taking the implementation of the"negative list"system nationwide in 2018 as a landmark event,based on the data of listed companies in China's manufacturing industry from 2011 to 2020,a quasi-natural experiment was carried out,and a variety of identification strategies were comprehensively used to test the impact effect and transmission mechanism of the re-laxation of foreign investment access policies on the innovation of Chinese manufacturing enterprises.The difference-in-difference model analysis shows that the implementation of the"negative list"system has a significant effect on the improve-ment of the innovation ability of Chinese manufacturing enterprises,and the conclusion is still valid after a series of robust-ness tests and placebo tests.The"negative list"system mainly promotes the improvement of the innovation ability of manufac-turing enterprises through three channels:the spillover effect,the competition effect and the correlation effect of FDI.The het-erogeneity analysis based on the new characteristics of the"quality"shift of FDI inflow into the manufacturing industry con-firms that the relaxation of foreign investment access policies has not led to the proliferation of low-level FDI,but has pro-moted the inflow of"high-quality"FDI,which has played a significant role in narrowing China's regional gap,forcing enter-prises to innovate,and promoting the development of high-tech and strategic industries.Finally,the analysis of the moderat-ing effect of the factors such as enterprises and social environment shows that the stronger the absorptive capacity of enter-prises,the lower the level of financing constraints and the higher the level of regional business environment,the more they can promote the policy effect of the"negative list"system.These findings have the following policy implications:(1)China should continue to optimize the"negative list"system,improve the quality of opening up,adjust foreign investment policies in a timely manner according to the situation of industrial development,and guide foreign investment in high-tech industries and strategic emerging industries;(2)we should pay more attention to grasping the combination of"government guidance"and"market leadership"to stimulate the vitality of market competition;(3)attach importance to supporting policy measures,accelerate the construction of a unified market,optimize the business environment for enterprises,and broaden the financing channels for small and medium-sized enterprises.This paper may have the following marginal contributions:First,it enriches the micro evidence of the impact of the relaxation of foreign investment access policies on manufacturing innovation,and pro-vides theoretical and empirical evidence for China's continuous expansion of opening-up in the new era and guiding the trans-formation of foreign investment from"quantity excellence"to"quality excellence";Second,it deepens the understanding of the path of foreign investment on the innovation mechanism of domestic manufacturing enterprises,which is helpful to enrich the understanding of the mechanism of major macro policies on micro enterprises;Thirdly,the enterprise factors,industrial factors and social environmental factors are included in an analytical framework,which comprehensively reveals the impact of foreign investment on the innovation ability of domestic enterprises,and enriches the research attempts on the impact of sup-porting measures.

Negative listFDIManufacturingEnterprise Innovation

宋赛虎、李娜

展开 >

集美大学财经学

集美大学财经学院

集美大学地方财政绩效研究中心 361021

负面清单 FDI 制造业 企业创新

国家自然科学基金委员会面上项目福建省社科联基地重大项目福建省科技创新战略研究联合项目资助福建省高校创新团队发展计划(IRTSTFJ)

41971261FJ2020JDZ0382022R0140

2024

南方经济
广东经济学会 广东省社会科学院

南方经济

CSSCICHSSCD北大核心
影响因子:0.925
ISSN:1000-6249
年,卷(期):2024.(2)
  • 1
  • 27