首页|"由史入论":英美情报研究路径之比较

"由史入论":英美情报研究路径之比较

扫码查看
[研究目的]情报研究是西方学界社会科学研究的重要组成部分.英美情报研究都发源于二战时期历史学者参与情报工作实践的经验,在战后均以情报史为基础开展研究.英国情报学界在情报史领域成果斐然,但其理论研究水平远逊于美国,形成了情报研究英国学派,两国体现出明显的研究路径分野.比较英美两国情报研究路径,可为我国情报研究提供参考.[研究方法]运用历史研究、文献分析、比较研究、归因分析等方法,系统梳理英美情报研究的发展历程,比较其异同之处,并探究其路径分野的原因.[研究结论]英美两国不同政治文化的影响,社会科学研究传统的差异,以及实践参与程度的不同,是两国情报研究路径分野的原因.情报研究应当以历史研究为基础,防止过度保密,积极推进理论与实践的交融.
"From History to Theory":A Comparison of British and American Intelligence Studies Approaches
[Research purpose]Intelligence study is an important part of social science research in the western academic community.Both British and American intelligence studies originated from the experience of historians involved in the practice of intelligence during World War Ⅱ,and further developed based on the intelligence history after the war.However,the British intelligence studies community has made outstanding achievements only in the field of intelligence history,and its theoretical study is far inferior to that of the United States,forming the British School of intelligence studies,and there is an obvious division of study approaches in the two countries.A comparison of their intelligence studies approaches can provide reference for China's intelligence studies.[Research method]Using historical re-search,literature analysis,comparative research,reason analysis and other methods,this paper sorts out the development history of British and American intelligence studies,compares their similarities and differences,and explores the reasons for their division of study approa-ches.[Research conclusion]The study finds that the influence of different political cultures,the differences in social science research tra-ditions,and the different degrees of practical participation in the two countries are the reasons for the division.Intelligence study should be based on historical study,prevent excessive secrecy,and actively promote the integration of theory and practice.

intelligence studiesintelligence historyintelligence theoryintelligence workthe United Kingdomthe United Stateslitera-ture analysis method

武洋、高金虎、马琼诗

展开 >

海军指挥学院 南京 210016

国防科技大学国际关系学院 南京 210039

情报研究 情报史 情报理论 情报工作 英国 美国 文献分析法

国家社会科学基金军事学重大项目国防科技大学教育教学重点研究课题

2023-SKJJ-A-010U2022208

2024

情报杂志
陕西省科学技术信息研究所

情报杂志

CSTPCDCSSCICHSSCD北大核心
影响因子:1.502
ISSN:1002-1965
年,卷(期):2024.43(2)
  • 63