情报杂志2024,Vol.43Issue(6) :177-184.DOI:10.3969/j.issn.1002-1965.2024.06.024

数据新闻可视化信息误导分析框架与误导方式

The Misleading Analysis Framework and Misleading Methods of Data Visualization in Data Journalism

郝珊 魏修治
情报杂志2024,Vol.43Issue(6) :177-184.DOI:10.3969/j.issn.1002-1965.2024.06.024

数据新闻可视化信息误导分析框架与误导方式

The Misleading Analysis Framework and Misleading Methods of Data Visualization in Data Journalism

郝珊 1魏修治2
扫码查看

作者信息

  • 1. 上海大学上海美术学院 上海 200444
  • 2. 合肥大学语言文化与传媒学院 合肥 230601
  • 折叠

摘要

[研究目的]近年来数据新闻可视化信息误导频发,带来新闻与信息安全问题和治理压力.研究分析数据新闻可视化信息误导的框架并识别误导方式,能为核查与防范误导以及培养数字素养提供参考与启示.[研究方法]通过梳理整合相关领域可视化信息误导文献,并结合近年错误案例,构建理论分析框架并整理具体误导方式.[研究结论]借鉴可视分析框架与数据新闻生产消费流程,搭建数据采集分析、可视化设计、叙事编辑、图文排版及阅读消费5 阶段组成的数据新闻可视化误导分析管道.其后根据设计实践流程细分 11 个子阶段,并归纳其中 73 种详细的误导方式.最后从理解与修正误导、学科细分深入、认知和教育角度对未来研究进行展望.

Abstract

[Research purpose]In recent years,there has been a surge in misleading information in data journalism visualization,leading to challenges in news and information security and governance.Analyzing the framework of misleading information in data journalism vi-sualization and identifying misleading methods can provide valuable insights for fact-checking,prevention of misinformation,and enhan-cing digital literacy.[Research method]This study involved a review and synthesis of relevant literature on visual misinformation and a-nalysis recent erroneous cases.A theoretical analysis framework was constructed,and specific misleading methods were categorized based on this framework.[Research conclusion]Drawing from visual analysis frameworks and the data journalism production-consumption process,we developed a pipeline for analyzing misleading information in data journalism visualization,consisting of five stages:data col-lection analysis,visualization design,narrative editing,paper layout,and reader consumption.Subsequently,11 sub-stages were identi-fied within the design and practice process,encompassing 73 detailed misleading methods.Finally,the study provides insights into future research from the perspectives of understanding and correcting misinformation,deepening disciplinary specialization,and cognitive educa-tion.

关键词

数据新闻/数据可视化/信息安全/数据误导/信息误导/误导方式/数字素养

Key words

data journalism/data visualization/information security/data misleading/misinformation/misleading method/digital litera-cy

引用本文复制引用

基金项目

国家留学基金艺术类人才培养特别项目(CSC202006890038)

安徽省哲学社会科学规划项目(AHSKQ2022D019)

出版年

2024
情报杂志
陕西省科学技术信息研究所

情报杂志

CSTPCDCSSCICHSSCD北大核心
影响因子:1.502
ISSN:1002-1965
段落导航相关论文