智慧边境建设是保障中国边境安全、维系国家地缘安全和实现可持续发展的核心议题.以web of science为数据源,利用Cite Space解析智慧边境研究特征及国外研究进展,并展望未来研究方向.结果表明:智慧边境研究尚处于起步阶段,发文数量呈波动上升趋势,但研究关注度较低.智慧边境研究群体分布分散,仅存在少量合作关系,尚未形成紧密的合作性作者网络,美国、英国、中国、加拿大、德国是研究智慧边境较多的国家.边境安全是智慧边境研究最关注的话题,移民管理和智能监控是智慧边境建设的重点.智慧边境研究主要围绕智慧边境内涵、智慧边境需求、智慧边境系统、预警机制构建、再边境化与智慧化和边境战略与跨境合作6个议题展开.未来,智慧边境研究应深化智慧边境理论与方法创新,开展中国智慧边境管控体系构建,加强通道精准管控与预警研究,探究多主体联动与人性化治理模式.
Advances and Prospects in Smart Border Studies Based on a Bibliometric Analysis
The construction of smart borders has become a key issue in ensuring China's border security,maintaining the country's geopolitical stability,and promoting sustainable development.Against the backdrop of a changing global security landscape,particularly the increasing likelihood of non-traditional security threats,such as cybercrime,terrorism,and environmental risks,the need for a more sophisticated technology-driven approach to border management has become ever-more pressing.By quantitatively analyzing the literature related to smart borders between 2001 and 2022,using CiteSpace software and the Web of Science database as a data source,we aim in this paper to provide a comprehensive review of the development of the field of smart border research,to assess the hotspots and themes of current research,and consider future directions in the field.The results of the study revealed that smart border research is still very much in its infancy,and although there has been a general upward trend in the number of published articles,the volume of relevant research is still comparatively low.Furthermore,the distribution of smart border research groups appears to be relatively decentralized,with only a small number of collaborative initiatives to date,and,as yet,no prominent networked group of authors,with a large proportion of the research being conducted in the United States,the United Kingdom,China,Canada,and Germany.Among the topics addressed in smart border research,border security appears to be the subject of most concern,with immigration management and intelligent surveillance being particular focuses of smart border construction.On the basis of our review,we identified six areas that are the primary focus of current smart border research,namely,the connotation of smart borders,smart border demand,smart border systems,early warning mechanism construction,re-bordering and intelligence,and border strategy and cross-border cooperation.As an emerging research field,despite the preliminary results,smart border studies are still facing problems relating to practical application,such as weak theoretical foundations,an insufficiently developed methodological basis,and conflict between"human defense"and"smart defense,"Our findings highlight the need for future studies to focus on establishing a sound theoretical and methodological framework underpinning smart border research,building a smart border control system adapted to China's national conditions,strengthening the precise control and early warning research of border corridors,and examining the modes of multi-subject linkage and humanized governance.Through interdisciplinary integration,drawing on international experience,and promoting the innovation of technology and governance models,the construction of China's smart borders can effectively respond to both traditional and non-traditional security threats,and enhance the precision and efficiency of border management.Having surveyed the current state of smart border research,we propose the following steps to promote the development of China's smart borders.Firstly,smart borders should be comprehensively integrated into the national security strategy to ensure that the system meets China's specific border security needs.A smart border management model with Chinese characteristics should be constructed,emphasizing data sharing,technological interoperability,and coordination and cooperation among all parties.Secondly,with a view toward enhancing border management efficiency,it is recommended that interdisciplinary cooperation be strengthened,international best practices be drawn upon,and technological innovations be promoted.Given the efficient implementation of these measures,China will be able to respond more effectively to traditional and non-traditional security threats,ensure border security and efficient management,and thus maintain stability and sustainable development within an increasingly complex global security environment.
smart bordersborder securitynational geo-securityborder control systemresearch progressresearch outlookbibliometrics
万方数据
维普
