首页|告子是禅?——宋明理学儒释之辨的一个议题

告子是禅?——宋明理学儒释之辨的一个议题

扫码查看
理学兴起后,辨儒释、攻异端便成为理学家的重要课题.在重新审视儒学史上的孟、告之辨时,理学家发现告子所云诸多言论与禅宗"蠢动含灵皆有佛性""作用是性"颇有相似处,因此提出"告子是禅"这一命题,直将告子视为禅宗祖师.不仅如此,理学家"告子是禅"也关联着他们对霸儒、异统的批判.朱子及其弟子屡次将告子之学与陆象山相联系,而李材、顾宪成、刁包、熊赐履等人则将告子之学与王阳明相联系.既然告子是禅,那么陆象山、王阳明无疑也是禅.批驳告子,即可收到清理儒学门户、攻驳陆王的效果.不过,"告子是禅"也引起佛门释子及好佛士人的不满,麦浪明怀、曾凤仪等人曾对此予以严正驳斥.告子是禅抑或非禅,成为宋明时期儒释辩论的一个热门议题.
Is Kao-tzu Zen Buddhism:A Neo-Confucian Discussion about the Difference between Confucianism and Buddhism
Since the appearance of neo-Confucianism,it has become an important task for Confucian scholars to distinguish the difference between Confucianism and Buddhism.To review the difference between Mencius and Kao-tzu,scholars discovered the theories of Kao-tzu were highly close to Zen Buddhism.Kao-tzu was then consid-ered Zen Buddhism,which became a catchword to attack Buddhism and some Confucianists.Zhu Xi and his disci-ples often related Lu Jiuyuan to Kao-tzu,while Li Cai,Gu Xiancheng,Diao Bao,and Xiong Cilv related Wang Yangming to Kao-tzu.If Kao-tzu was Zen Buddhism,then Lu Jiuyuan and Wang Yangming were also Buddhism.Attacking Kao-tzu became a significant task in clearing heresies in Confucianism and censuring Lu and Wang.However,such a catchword evoked disagreements among Buddhist monks and Buddhists like Shi Minghuai and Zeng Fengyi.Whether Kao-tzu is Zen Buddhism or not has then become a topic of interest in the debate between Confucianism and Buddhism during the Song and Ming dynasties.

Kao-tzuBuddhismZhu XiWang Yangmingthe difference between Confucianism and Bud-dhism

牛磊

展开 >

北京体育大学 中国武术学院,北京 100084

告子 朱熹 王阳明 儒释之辨

2025

山东青年政治学院学报
山东青年政治学院

山东青年政治学院学报

影响因子:0.387
ISSN:1008-7605
年,卷(期):2025.41(1)