海关与经贸研究2024,Vol.45Issue(4) :61-78.

气候措施适用WTO可用竭自然资源例外规则之检视

Reflection on the Application of WTO's Exception Rule for the Conservation of Exhaustible Natural Resources to Climate Measures

傅子洛
海关与经贸研究2024,Vol.45Issue(4) :61-78.

气候措施适用WTO可用竭自然资源例外规则之检视

Reflection on the Application of WTO's Exception Rule for the Conservation of Exhaustible Natural Resources to Climate Measures

傅子洛1
扫码查看

作者信息

  • 1. 上海交通大学凯原法学院;香港理工大学商学院
  • 折叠

摘要

可用竭自然资源例外规则源于美国20世纪上半叶的自然资源保护运动,在全球环保运动中得以发展.如今,既有判例对该规则采用的演进式解释方法及人类、动植物生命健康例外规则的"必要性"要件门槛,驱使着该规则成为判断气候措施在WTO规则下合法性的关键.在"清洁空气"、"气候系统"类概念和"受气候变化影响的自然资源"中,"气候系统"类概念是核心分析对象,其是否属于"可用竭自然资源"在自然资源永久主权原则下值得深思.以应对气候变化名义实施的气候措施能否满足"保护的相关性"和"非歧视性"要件存在一定不确定性.这客观上为WTO争端解决机构考量国际气候规则体系中的共同但有区别的责任原则、国际合作原则提供了空间.

Abstract

The WTO's exception rule for the conservation of exhaustible natural resources traces its roots to the natural resource conservation movement in the United States during the first half of the 20th century,and has since evolved within the global environmental protection movement.Nowadays,the evolutionary interpretation of this rule in precedent cases,coupled with the"necessity"threshold of the exception rule concerning human,animal and plant life health,has positioned GATT XX(g)as a pivotal determinant of the legality of climate measures under WTO rules.Among various concepts,in-cluding"clean air","climate system"related concepts and"natural resources affected by climate change",the concepts related to the"climate system"emerge as a central analytical object.Whether these notions fall under the umbrella of"exhaustible natural resources"merits careful consideration in light of the principle of permanent sovereignty over natural resources.Some uncertainty surrounds whether climate measures,undertaken in the name of tackling climate change,satisfy the criteria of"protection relevance"or"non-discrimination"or not.To an extent,such uncertainty offers the WTO dispute settlement bodies latitude to take into account principles from the international climate change law,specifically the principle of common but differentiated responsibilities and the principle of interna-tional cooperation.

关键词

气候变化/气候措施/WTO例外规则/可用竭自然资源例外规则

Key words

Climate Change/Climate Measures/WTO Exception Rule/Exhaustible Natural Re-sources Exception Rule

引用本文复制引用

出版年

2024
海关与经贸研究
上海海关学校

海关与经贸研究

影响因子:0.451
ISSN:1674-1765
段落导航相关论文