首页|联邦权与州权的平衡:约翰·马歇尔对州治安权的阐释及其运用

联邦权与州权的平衡:约翰·马歇尔对州治安权的阐释及其运用

The Balance of Federal and State Powers:John Marshall's Interpretation and Application of State Police Power

扫码查看
约翰·马歇尔是美国第四任首席大法官.在早期美国州权主义强势、政党纷争不已的背景下,他带领最高法院的同仁,通过对宪法文本的阐释,极大地加强了联邦权,削弱了州权,引发了州权主义者的猛烈批评.不过,马歇尔并非积极的国家主义者,他在相关案件中对州治安权的阐释及其案例判决表明,马歇尔及这一时期最高法院的大法官们都清楚地意识到,各州在其治安权的管辖范围内,依然行使着州内治理等大量政府功能,应该予以肯定和支持.实际上,联邦保有宪法列举的必要且至上的权力,而各州保留剩余的权力,联邦权与州权平衡互动,这不仅是制宪精英们的意图,也是现实的需求.
John Marshall,the fourth Chief Justice of the United States,played a pivotal role in expanding federal power while limiting the authority of the states through his interpretation of the Constitution.This ap-proach sparked strong opposition from advocates of states'rights.Despite this,Marshall was not an aggres-sive nationalist.His rulings on cases involving state police power revealed that he,along with his fellow jus-tices,recognized the important role states played in governing within their police powers.These powers,they believed,should be preserved and respected.In practice,the federal government exercises the powers ex-pressly granted by the Constitution,while states retain authority over matters not explicitly delegated.This dynamic,characterized by a balance of federal and state powers,reflects both the framers'intentions and the practical demands of governance.

United States Supreme CourtJohn Marshallstate police powerfederal power

郭巧华

展开 >

福建师范大学社会历史学院,福建 福州 350007

美国最高法院 约翰·马歇尔 州治安权 联邦权

2025

史学集刊
吉林大学

史学集刊

北大核心
影响因子:0.374
ISSN:0559-8095
年,卷(期):2025.(1)