世界农药2024,Vol.46Issue(12) :1-4,25.DOI:10.16201/j.cnki.cn10-1660/tq.2024.12.01

基于巴斯夫吡唑醚菌酯专利无效案看马库什权利要求撰写——评(2021)最高法知行终第519号二审判决

On Markush claim drafting based on BASF's pyraclostrobin patent invalidation case——Comment on the second-instance judgment of the supreme court intellectual property execution final No.519(2021)

司丽春 王岩 曹巧利
世界农药2024,Vol.46Issue(12) :1-4,25.DOI:10.16201/j.cnki.cn10-1660/tq.2024.12.01

基于巴斯夫吡唑醚菌酯专利无效案看马库什权利要求撰写——评(2021)最高法知行终第519号二审判决

On Markush claim drafting based on BASF's pyraclostrobin patent invalidation case——Comment on the second-instance judgment of the supreme court intellectual property execution final No.519(2021)

司丽春 1王岩 1曹巧利2
扫码查看

作者信息

  • 1. 北京悦和知识产权代理有限公司,北京 100050
  • 2. 陕西美邦药业集团股份有限公司,西安 710018
  • 折叠

摘要

为了对马库什权利要求的撰写提出可行性建议,对吡唑醚菌酯复配组合物专利ZL98805666.6号发明专利权无效案的审理进行了重点梳理.除了创造性,该专利无效案的争议焦点还在于无效阶段马库什权利要求的修改方式.建议根据无效程序对于马库什权利要求的修改要求,在申请阶段提高申请文本的撰写质量.

Abstract

In order to make feasible suggestions on the drafting of Markush claims,the trial of the invalidation case of the invention patent right No.ZL98805666.6 of the pyraclostrobin compound composition patent was reviewed.In addition to the creativity,the focus of the dispute in the patent invalidation case is also the modification method of the Markush claims at the invalidation stage.It is recommended to improve the drafting quality of the application text at the application stage according to the modification requirements of the Markush claims in the invalidation procedure.

关键词

马库什权利要求/专利无效/权利要求的修改/专利侵权诉讼/吡唑醚菌酯/复配组合物专利

Key words

Markush claims/patent invalidity/amendment of claims/patent infringement litigation/pyraclostrobin/patent for mixed pesticide composition

引用本文复制引用

出版年

2024
世界农药
上海市农药研究所

世界农药

影响因子:0.494
ISSN:1009-6485
段落导航相关论文