沉默的辩白——李征《关于<坎曼尔诗签>的问题》考略
Silent Defense:A Brief Review of Li Zheng's On the Issues about Kammel Poems
刘子凡1
作者信息
- 1. 中国社会科学院古代史研究所、敦煌学研究中心
- 折叠
摘要
《坎曼尔诗签》是曾产生过重大社会影响的文书.杨镰利用新疆博物馆原工作人员施传惠昌的证词,称诗签系李征主谋伪造,其观点亦对李征造成很大负面影响.黄烈曾受郭沫若著作编委会委托赴新疆调查诗签发现始末,保留了李征撰写《关于<坎曼尔诗签>的问题》材料及谈话记录的复印件.这些资料是李征根据组织要求,对诗签问题发表的审慎负责的意见.李征因家学和工作背景,高度关注这两件出土文书,认为是极有价值的文物,但怀疑经手者有破坏文物的行为.同时,他积极建议对文物进行科学鉴定.结合以上事实以及李征对文物考古事业认真负责的行止和品格来看,李征不可能是"坎曼尔诗签"的作伪者.
Abstract
"The Kammel Poems"are the documents that have a great social impact.Yang Lian used the testimony of someone,a former staff member of the Xinjiang Museum,to claim that the poems were forged by Li Zheng,which also had a great negative impact on Li Zheng.Huang Lie was entrusted by the editori-al board of Guo Moruo's works to go to Xinjiang to investigate the whole story of the discovery of the Po-em and retained a copy of"On the Issues about'Kammel Poems'"written by Li Zheng and conversation records.These materials are Li Zheng's prudent and responsible opinions on the issue of poem in accor-dance with the requirements of the organization.Because of his family education and work background,Li Zheng paid much close attention to these two unearthed documents and considered them to be extremely valuable cultural relics.However,he suspected that those who handled them had damaged the cultural relics.At the same time,he actively suggested scientific identification of cultural relics.Based on the above facts and Li Zheng's serious and responsible behavior and character for cultural relics and archae-ology,it is impossible for Li Zheng to forger the"Kammel Poems".
关键词
坎曼尔诗签/李征/施惠昌/调查材料Key words
Kammel Poems/Li Zheng/Shi Huichang/Investigation Materials引用本文复制引用
出版年
2024
NETL
NSTL
万方数据