文物保护与考古科学2024,Vol.36Issue(1) :21-31.DOI:10.16334/j.cnki.cn31-1652/k.20231103087

基于拉曼光谱半定量分析的铁质文物锈层"保护能力指数"评估——以"南海Ⅰ号"沉船出水铁条为例

Protective ability index measurement by Raman spectrometry to assess the stability of iron objects:a case study of an iron bar from the Nanhai No.1 shipwreck

刘薇 吴娜 程枭翔
文物保护与考古科学2024,Vol.36Issue(1) :21-31.DOI:10.16334/j.cnki.cn31-1652/k.20231103087

基于拉曼光谱半定量分析的铁质文物锈层"保护能力指数"评估——以"南海Ⅰ号"沉船出水铁条为例

Protective ability index measurement by Raman spectrometry to assess the stability of iron objects:a case study of an iron bar from the Nanhai No.1 shipwreck

刘薇 1吴娜 1程枭翔2
扫码查看

作者信息

  • 1. 中国国家博物馆文保院,北京 100079;金属文物保护国家文物局重点科研基地(中国国家博物馆),北京 100079
  • 2. 北京科技大学科技史与文化遗产研究院,北京 100083
  • 折叠

摘要

铁质文物锈蚀产物的稳定性对文物本体的保存与保护具有较大影响,对锈层稳定性的判断是评估铁质文物整体保存状况的关键步骤."保护能力指数"(PAI)是锈蚀稳定相与不稳定相的含量比值,可用于评估铁质文物的锈蚀程度及腐蚀趋势.近来拉曼光谱越来越多地被用作一种半定量方法,可用于计算混合铁质文物锈蚀产物的各组分含量,因此,可利用该方法计算铁锈的PAI值.本研究利用激光拉曼光谱方法,并结合大幅面X射线荧光成像等多种方法手段,以"南海Ⅰ号"出水一件铁条文物为例,对其锈蚀产物进行半定量分析,并计算出锈蚀PAI值.结果表明,铁条主要包含α-FeOOH、γ-FeOOH、β-FeOOH及Fe304四种锈蚀产物,不同种类的锈蚀在内外层的分布规律有一定差异.铁条锈蚀PAI值波动范围较大,最低为0.34,最高为20.38,PAI值主要分布于1~10之间.内外锈层的PAI值不同:外层锈蚀PAI值相对较高,说明锈蚀较为稳定;层状剥离面锈蚀PAI值<1,表明锈蚀非常不稳定;内层锈蚀PAI值最低为0.73,说明存在不稳定锈蚀.铁质文物锈蚀产物PAI值为科学评估文物的保存状况提供了定量、可靠的方法.

Abstract

The stability of corrosion products on iron artifacts has significant effects on the preservation and conservation of the objects.This is a crucial factor in evaluating the overall conservation state of iron objects.The protective ability index(PAI),which primarily considers the ratio of stable phase to unstable phases,is applied to assess the protective ability of the corrosion layer and the corrosion tendency of iron objects.Recently,Raman spectrometry has been more often used as a semi-quantitative approach for quantifying various components of iron corrosion,making it a valuable tool for calculating the PAI value.In this study,Raman spectrometry,combined with macro X-ray florescence imaging and other techniques,was applied to quantify the composition of corrosion products on an iron bar excavated from the Nanhai No.1 shipwreck.Subsequently,the PAI values were calculated.The results indicate that the corrosion products predominantly comprise four types:α-FeOOH,γ-FeOOH,β-FeOOH and Fe3O4.These products present distinct distribution patterns in the inner and outer layers of the object.The PAI values ranged primarily from 1 to 10,with the lowest recorded at 0.34 and highest at 20.38.Notably,the PAI values for corrosion in outer layer are higher than those in the inner layer,suggesting greater stability in the outer rust.Corrosion present at the stripping surface,with a PAI value below 1,is indicative of significant instability.Similarly,instances of unstable corrosion were observed within the inner layer,as evidenced by a PAI value of 0.73.The application of PAI values in assessing iron corrosion provides a quantitative and reliable method for diagnosing the conservation state of iron objects.

关键词

铁质文物/锈蚀产物/保护能力指数/稳定性评估

Key words

Iron object/Corrosion product/PAI/Stability assessment

引用本文复制引用

基金项目

国家重点研发计划项目(2020YFC1522100)

国家重点研发计划项目(2020YFC1522101)

出版年

2024
文物保护与考古科学
上海博物馆

文物保护与考古科学

CSTPCDCHSSCD北大核心
影响因子:0.453
ISSN:1005-1538
参考文献量28
段落导航相关论文