首页|汉-英-法三语者的三语句法表征研究——来自跨语言句法启动的证据

汉-英-法三语者的三语句法表征研究——来自跨语言句法启动的证据

扫码查看
本文以不同三语水平的汉-英-法三语者为研究对象,通过两个跨语言句法启动实验,探究三语句法与一语、二语句法是否共享及其影响因素。研究发现,不同水平三语者的一语与三语之间发生了跨语言句法启动,但二语与三语之间未发生跨语言句法启动。这说明,不同三语水平的汉-英-法三语者能够首先实现一语与三语的句法共享;而二语与三语的句法始终未能实现共享,二者是独立表征,这主要与三语者的二语水平较低有关。在三语句法表征中,母语因素的作用大于语序一致性。根据本研究结果,我们对多语句法共享说进行了补充。三种语言中对应的句法结构能否实现句法共享不能一概而论:由于母语具有稳固的抽象句法表征,即使语序不完全一致,三语也能够逐渐与一语实现句法共享;而二语与三语能否实现句法共享则受到二语水平的显著影响。
Syntactic representations for the three languages in Chinese-English-French trilinguals:Evidence from cross-linguistic priming
This study investigates whether syntax is shared between the first language(L1)and third language(L3)and between the second language(L2)and L3 as well as what factors influence syntactic representations for the three languages in Chinese-English-French trilinguals.Two cross-linguistic syntactic priming experiments were conducted with trilinguals with high and low L3 proficiency.The results show that cross-linguistic syntactic priming occurred between L1 and L3 in both the high and low L3 proficiency groups,but such a priming effect was not observed between L2 and L3 in either group.These findings indicate that during the learning process,a shared syntactic representation is first achieved between L1 and L3,while the syntactic representations of L2 and L3 remain independent,largely owing to relatively low L2 proficiency.The results also suggest that the influence of L1 on syntactic representations for the three languages is stronger than that of word-order similarity.Based on these findings,this study extends the shared syntax account across languages(Hartsuiker et al.2016).Because of the stable syntactic representation of L1,the corresponding structures in L1 and L3 usually share a syntactic representation even if the word orders between the two languages are not identical.In contrast to L1 and L3,the sharing of syntactic representations of equivalent structures in L2 and L3 largely depends on L2 proficiency.Therefore,whether there is a shared syntactic representation for all three languages of trilinguals may vary greatly depending on the circumstances.

缪小米、夏全胜

展开 >

南开大学

北京师范大学

三语句法表征 跨语言句法启动 三语水平 母语因素 语序一致性

夏全胜主持的天津市哲学社会科学重点课题

TJYY23-005

2024

外语教学与研究
北京外国语大学

外语教学与研究

CSTPCDCSSCICHSSCD北大核心
影响因子:3.149
ISSN:1000-0429
年,卷(期):2024.56(5)