首页|科技成果的文化影响概念框架与REF2021案例研究

科技成果的文化影响概念框架与REF2021案例研究

扫码查看
[目的]分析国外科技成果的文化影响案例,为我国科技成果的文化价值评估提供参考.[方法]建立16个文化影响类别和4类研究成果概念框架并借助Notion AI工具,完成英国REF2021影响评估案例中科技医药领域的29个文化影响案例的影响类别和成果类别标引,对案例文本进行结构化分析.[结果]分析结果揭示了科技医药领域文化影响类别的丰富多样性,最突出的类别为"参与或被应用到各类传媒或文化载体中",不同学科与不同类型的研究成果的文化影响表现具有差异性.[局限]案例数量偏少,所建立的文化影响概念框架有待进一步完善,未包含对文化意识形态方面的影响分析等.[结论]本文所提文化影响的概念框架有助于解释案例文本;不同学科和不同类型研究成果的文化影响差异揭示了分类评价的必要性和意义;文化影响的概念框架还有待进一步扩展才能更好地为评估决策提供支持.
Conceptual Framework for Cultural Impacts of Scientific Research and REF2021 Cases
[Objective]This study analyzes the cultural impact cases of foreign scientific research.It provides references for the cultural value assessment of scientific achievements in China.[Methods]We established a conceptual framework for 16 cultural impact categories and four types of research outcomes.Then,we analyze 29 cultural impact cases in medical science and technology from the UK REF2021 impact assessment.Finally,we conducted a structured analysis of case texts using the Notion AI tool.[Results]This study identified the rich diversity of cultural impact categories in medical science and technology.The most prominent category is"participation or application in various media or cultural carriers".The cultural impact of different disciplines and types of research outcomes exhibits differences.[Limitations]The study has a limited number of cases.The conceptual framework for cultural impact needs further improvement.It does not include an analysis of the impact on cultural ideologies.[Conclusions]The proposed cultural impact framework helps to interpret case texts.The differences in cultural impact between different disciplines and types of research outcomes highlight the necessity and significance of categorical evaluation.The conceptual framework of cultural impacts needs to be expanded to better support decision-making for assessment.

Research Results in STM DomainCultural Impact AssessmentCultural Impact CategoriesCase Text Structured Analysis

曾燕、昝婷婷、杨晓、屈明剑

展开 >

中国科学院文献情报中心 北京 100190

科技部科技评估中心 北京 100081

中国科学院大学经济与管理学院信息资源管理系 北京 100190

科技成果 文化影响评估 文化影响类别 案例文本结构化分析

科技部科技评估中心评估研究专项

YJZX2022-2

2024

数据分析与知识发现
中国科学院文献情报中心

数据分析与知识发现

CSTPCDCSSCICHSSCD北大核心EI
影响因子:1.452
ISSN:2096-3467
年,卷(期):2024.8(5)
  • 29